We use cookies to enhance your experience on our website. By continuing to use our website, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. You can change your cookie settings at any time.
Find out more
Jump to Content
Jump to Main Navigation
User Account
Personal Profile:
Sign in
or
Create
See all online law products
More
About
Guided Tour
Subscriber Services
Contact Us
FAQ
Help
Search
Browse all
Area of law
Financial Law [FBL]
International Commercial Arbitration [ICMA]
Private International Law [PRIL]
International Commercial Law [ICML]
Author
My Content
(0)
Recently viewed
(0)
Save Entry
My Searches
(0)
Recently viewed
(0)
Save Search
Print
Save
Cite
Email this content
Share This
Subscriber sign in
You could not be signed in, please check and try again.
Username
Please enter your Username
Password
Please enter your Password
Forgotten your password?
Don't have an account?
Sign in via your Institution
You could not be signed in, please check and try again.
Sign in with your library card
Please enter your library card number
View translated passages only
Oxford Law Citator
Contents
Expand All
Collapse All
Preliminary Material
Preface to the Fourth Edition
Preface to the First Edition
Contents
Table of Cases
United Kingdom
European Union
Cases from Other National Jurisdictions
Argentina
Australia
Austria
Belgium
Brazil
Bulgaria
Canada
Chile
China
Denmark
Finland
France
Germany
Greece
Hong Kong
Hungary
Israel
Italy
Mexico
Netherlands
New Zealand
Poland
Russia
Serbia
Singapore
Slovakia
Slovenia
Spain
Sweden
Switzerland
Ukraine
United States
Vietnam
International Chamber of Commerce
Table of Legislation
United Kingdom
Statutory Instruments
European Union
Treaties
Regulations
Directives
CISG
National Legislation From Other Jurisdictions
France
United States
Main Text
Part I International Sales Governed by English Law
Preliminary Material
1 Introduction to International Sales
Preliminary Material
A Subject Matter
Introduction
Scope
1.01
Commodities
1.02
UN Sale Convention
1.03
Comparison with English law
1.04
Shipping terms
Defining delivery
1.05
Excluding domestic sales
1.06
Documents instead of goods
1.07
CIF and FOB
1.08
A common transaction
General
1.09
New York shipment
1.10
Variety of contracts
1.11
Other contracts
1.12
Payment
1.13
After discharge
1.14
CIF
1.15
The above example atypical
1.16
B Organizations and Entities
UNCITRAL
1.17
Unidroit
1.18
International Chamber of Commerce
1.19
Trade associations
1.20
Standard form contracts
1.21
Traders
1.22
State intervention
1.23
C Choice of Law
Sources
1.24
Universal rules
1.25
Arbitration
1.26
Interpretation
1.27
Party autonomy
1.28
Split choice
1.29
Floating applicable law
1.30
Stateless applicable law
1.31
Mandatory (non-derogable) rules
1.32
Overriding mandatory provisions
1.33
Public policy
1.34
Presumptive applicable law
1.35
Characteristic performance
1.36
Displacing characteristic performance
1.37
Scope of the applicable law
1.38
Illegality
1.39
The CISG
1.40
Contractual foreign elements
1.41
D Speculation, Hedging, and String Trading
Market liquidity
1.42
Forward delivery
1.43
Wagers
1.44
Need to plan ahead
1.45
Sales strings
1.46
Closing out
1.47
Futures contracts
1.48
Financial services legislation
1.49
Exceptions
1.50
CR Sugar Trading
1.51
The Financial Services and Markets Act 2000
1.52
Oil trade
1.53
Standard oil contracts
1.54
Daisy chains
1.55
Converting to physical delivery
1.56
Availability for nominations
1.57
Seller’s option?
1.58
Balancing commitments
1.59
Example
1.60
Hedging
1.61
Standard products
1.62
Physical production
1.63
2 The Performance Obligations of Seller and Buyer in English Law
Preliminary Material
Sale of Goods Act 1979
2.01
Contract law
2.02
A Interpretation of the Contract
A matter of law
2.03
Harmonious interpretation
2.04
Eiusdem generis
2.05
Avoiding absurd results
2.06
Upholding the validity of the contract
2.07
Typed and standard clauses
2.08
Ambiguity and extrinsic evidence
2.09
Factual matrix
2.10
Rectification
2.11
Obvious mistakes
2.12
Rectification and evidence
2.13
The meaning of documents
2.14
Criticism of modern developments
2.15
Interpretation and implied terms
2.16
Reasonable interpretation and implied terms
2.17
Time of interpretation
2.18
Estoppel by convention
2.19
B Implied Terms of Quality, Fitness, and Description in International Commodity Sales
Description
General
2.20
Sale by description
2.21
Content of description
2.22
Reliance and opinion
2.23
Fitness for purpose
Introduction
2.24
Disclosure and undertaking
2.25
Reliance
2.26
Partial reliance
2.27
Purpose and case illustration
2.28
Further illustration
2.29
Satisfactory quality
Introduction
2.30
Dual purpose goods
2.31
Contractual terms and termination
Classification of terms
2.32
International sales and the seller’s duties
2.33
Inspection
Inspection agencies
2.34
Merits of independent binding inspection
2.35
Controlling opportunism
2.36
A code of the seller’s duties
2.37
Exclusion clauses and description
2.38
Exclusion, description, and quality
2.39
Construction
2.40
Quality and condition
2.41
Quality certificates and sub-sales
2.42
Status of express quality terms
2.43
Letter of credit
2.44
Exclusion clauses in international sales
Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977
2.45
International supply
2.46
Delivery to a state and in a state
2.47
English law connection
2.48
C Quantity: Entire and Severable Contracts
Introduction
Entire and severable obligations
2.49
Strict obligation
2.50
Partial rejection
2.51
Distinguishing entire and severable contracts
Construction
2.52
Contrasting example
2.53
Option to sever
2.54
Option not exercised
2.55
Severable breach
2.56
Separate deliveries and separate contracts
2.57
Conditional contracts and quantity
2.58
D Privity of Contract
Introduction
2.59
Third party beneficiaries under the 1999 Act
2.60
Terms of the contract
2.61
‘Purports’
2.62
Statutory implied terms
2.63
Presumption of enforceability
2.64
Locked-in rights
2.65
Derivative rights and enforcement
2.66
Conclusion
2.67
3 FOB Contracts
Preliminary Material
Introduction
3.01
A Nature of FOB Contracts
Loading and delivery
Meaning of FOB (free on board)
3.02
FOB variants
3.03
FOB delivery
3.04
Types of FOB contract
Shipper and contract of carriage
3.05
Carrier as agent
3.06
Three main varieties
3.07
‘Classic FOB’
3.08
Seller arranges carriage
3.09
Seller’s relationship with carrier
3.10
Buyer employs forwarding agent
3.11
Criticism of terminology
3.12
Bill of lading
3.13
Cost of loading
Loading responsibilities
3.14
Unexpected costs
3.15
Stowing
3.16
Harbour and related costs
3.17
Involvement of the carrier
Charter party difficulties
3.18
Co-operating with the carrier
3.19
Responsibility for selecting the carrier
Nominating the ship
3.20
Shipping space
3.21
Small packages
3.22
FOB delivery and waiver
No unilateral waiver
3.23
Seller’s interest
3.24
B Readiness to Load
Nominating the ship
Timely nomination
3.25
Late nomination
3.26
Classification of term
3.27
Contractual condition
3.28
The buyer’s breach
3.29
Oil trade
3.30
Extension clauses and carrying costs
Notice of expected arrival
3.31
Termination and extension
3.32
Scope and invocation of extension right
3.33
Price or penalty
3.34
Effect of extension
3.35
Contractual variants
3.36
Construction difficulty
3.37
Exemption from carrying costs
3.38
Substituting the named ship
Presumptive position
3.39
Optional information
3.40
Complex nomination clauses
3.41
Restrictions on substitution
3.42
Express substitution clauses
3.43
Substitution: summary
3.44
Physical characteristics of ship
Suitability
3.45
Approaching the head seller
3.46
Sellers’ technical rights
3.47
Impossible ships
3.48
Business efficacy
3.49
Ship suitable for cargo
3.50
Buyer’s nomination and seller’s approval
Example
3.51
Reason for seller’s approval
3.52
Intermediate stipulation
3.53
Failure to consult port authority
3.54
Destination of goods
Seller’s interest
3.55
Export embargoes
3.56
Port congestion
Demurrage
3.57
Demurrage and extension of shipment
3.58
Seller’s argument
3.59
Buyer’s response
3.60
Conclusion
3.61
C Port of Shipment
No port identified in contract
Certainty
3.62
Range of ports
Choosing the port
3.63
Buyer’s presumptive choice
3.64
Late nomination by seller
3.65
Importance of shipment port
Stipulated port
3.66
D Shipment
Timely arrival of ship
Importance of time
3.67
Arrival of the ship
3.68
Making provision for delay
3.69
Express clause
3.70
Delivery and the buyer’s failure to provide a ship
3.71
Due date of arrival
Choosing the date within the loading range
3.72
Contractual variation
3.73
Oil trade
3.74
Seller’s loading responsibilities
Seller’s response to buyer’s loading demand
3.75
‘At buyer’s call’
3.76
‘Ready to be delivered’
3.77
Calling forward without delay
3.78
Contractual condition
3.79
Oil trade provisions
3.80
Laycan clauses
3.81
Evidence of completed loading
3.82
Late arrival and delayed loading
3.83
Loading rate
Speed of loading
3.84
Loading rate clauses
3.85
Loading rate guarantees and factual expectations
3.86
Charter parties
Demurrage liability and transfer
3.87
Loading rate guarantees and demurrage
3.88
Demurrage and dispatch
3.89
Sale and charter party distinct contracts
3.90
Buyer’s complaint
3.91
E Documentary Tender
General
Documentary sales
3.92
Bills of lading
On board bill of lading
3.93
Shipped notations
3.94
Non-conforming bill
3.95
Buyer’s conduct
3.96
Bill of lading as security
3.97
Forwarding the bill
3.98
Other documents
Certificates
3.99
Waiver
3.100
Price allowance
3.101
4 CIF Contracts
Preliminary Material
A The Nature of a CIF Transaction
Duties of the seller
General
4.01
CIF and delivery
4.02
Contracts akin to CIF
4.03
Country of origin
4.04
CIF seller’s documentary responsibilities
4.05
String selling
Sellers and shippers
4.06
Traders in string
4.07
CIF seller and carrier
Contract of carriage
4.08
Freight
4.09
Failure to arrive
4.10
Insurance windfall
4.11
Basis clauses
4.12
Documents and examination of the goods
The documents to be tendered
4.13
Examination
4.14
CIF and examination
4.15
The buyer’s commercial risk
4.16
Price allowance clauses
4.17
Contracts similar to CIF
Modified CIF or different contract
4.18
On shore delivery
4.19
Construction issues
4.20
‘Delivered’ clauses
4.21
Landed weights
4.22
Rye terms
4.23
B Notice of Appropriation/Declaration of Shipment
Purpose of notices of appropriation
General
4.24
Effect of notice
4.25
Notices and string contracts
4.26
String contracts and speculation
4.27
Features of notices of appropriation
Requirements of notices
4.28
Internal and external features of notice
4.29
Withdrawing notices
Curing defective notices
4.30
Offer to tender
4.31
Modern authority
4.32
Oil contracts
4.33
Notices, substitution, and force majeure
4.34
Arrival of first ship
4.35
Time and notices of appropriation
Timely relay of notices
4.36
Delay in transmission
4.37
Tactical behaviour
4.38
Overlapping shipment periods
4.39
String seller’s guarantee
4.40
Express clauses
4.41
Example
4.42
Inter-office contracts
4.43
Waiver of defective notices
Acceptance of notices without protest
4.44
Strict obligation and election
4.45
Contents of notice of appropriation
Internal features of the notice
4.46
Defective information
4.47
The ship’s name
4.48
‘Or better name’
4.49
Buyer’s rejection of notice
4.50
Notice and breach
4.51
Anticipatory repudiation?
4.52
C&F contracts and nomination clauses
4.53
C Timely Performance
Shipment
Date of shipment
4.54
Laycan and ETA clause issues
4.55
ETA clauses
4.56
Laycan clauses
4.57
Frustrating delay
4.58
Extension clauses
4.59
Meaning and proof of shipment
4.60
Importance of timely shipment
4.61
Third party shipper
4.62
Force majeure and prohibition of export
Shipment periods and prohibition
4.63
Express clauses
4.64
Limiting seller’s freedom
4.65
Effect of extension
4.66
Export restrictions
4.67
Notice of prohibition and force majeure
4.68
Choice of discharge port
Identifying the party who chooses
4.69
Date of buyer’s choice
4.70
Special cases
4.71
Port congestion
4.72
Suitability of buyer’s choice
4.73
D Bills of Lading
Types of bill of lading
Documentary performance
4.74
The required type of transport document
4.75
Transfer of rights and duties under the contract of carriage
4.76
The required type of bill
4.77
Pragmatic considerations
4.78
Rights against carrier
4.79
Document of title
4.80
Case law
4.81
‘Intended to be shipped’
4.82
Express clauses
4.83
Bulk shipments
4.84
Letters of indemnity
The need for an indemnity
4.85
Who provides the carrier’s indemnity?
4.86
Seller’s duty
4.87
Third party issues and indemnities
4.88
Bills of lading and timely shipment
Date of bill
4.89
Timely received for shipment bills
4.90
Hybrid bills
4.91
Ambiguous bills
4.92
Late shipment
4.93
Uninformative bills
4.94
Misdated bills and apparent conformity
4.95
Loss caused by documentary breach
4.96
Contents of bill of lading
Clean bills of lading
4.97
Meaning of ‘clean’
4.98
Alterations to bill
4.99
Clean bills and risk
4.100
Freight prepaid bills
4.101
Bills of lading and other documents
Inconsistencies in the documentary bundle
4.102
Quantitative inconsistencies
4.103
Correcting defects in the bill of lading
Exemption clauses
4.104
Defectiveness of bills
4.105
Strict construction
4.106
Custom and defective documents
4.107
Bill of lading and contract of carriage
The contract of carriage
4.108
Seller’s reasonable assumptions
4.109
Diverted ships
4.110
Deviation and conforming carriage contracts
4.111
Conforming contracts and usual routes
4.112
Bills of lading and conforming carriage contracts
4.113
Modifying bill of lading
4.114
Carriage of Goods by Sea Act 1992
4.115
Damages for documentary breach
4.116
Rejecting the goods
4.117
Identity of carrier
4.118
E Continuous Documentary Coverage
Trans-shipment
4.119
‘On shipment’
4.120
Goods or documents
4.121
Sellers’ election
4.122
Ship’s delivery orders
4.123
F Bill of Lading Supplemented by Charter Party
Charter party terms
4.124
Copy of the charter party
4.125
Prior dealings between the parties
4.126
Express provision
4.127
Unstated destination
4.128
G Delivery Orders and Bulk Shipments
Ship’s delivery orders
4.129
The ship’s undertaking
4.130
H Insurance Documents
Type of document required
Buyer’s documentary needs
4.131
Modern position
4.132
Valid and invalid insurance documents
4.133
The terms of cover
Insurance information
4.134
Usual and customary insurance
4.135
Other insurance matters
Insurance and safe arrival
4.136
Excess insurance
4.137
I Lawful and Effective Documents
Contracts of carriage and insurance
Supervening illegality
4.138
Illegality and effective sale documents
4.139
Frustration of related contracts
4.140
Risk
4.141
Trading with the enemy
Meaning of trading
4.142
J Other Documents
Invoice
4.143
Post-discharge inspection
4.144
K Documentary Tender and Exchange
Time rules
4.145
Contractual variation
4.146
Tender of documents
4.147
Place of tender
4.148
Draft bill of exchange
4.149
L Arrival of the Ship
Discharge at named port not integral to CIF contract
Unloading at the discharge port
4.150
CIF oil and discharge
Expected arrival and oil contracts
4.151
Notice of readiness or actual discharge?
4.152
Arrival date and delivery range
4.153
Oil contracts and notice of arrival
4.154
Construction problems
4.155
A different view
4.156
Purpose of notice
4.157
Computing notice
4.158
Effect of late notice
4.159
Details of the ship
Physical characteristics of the ship
4.160
Demurrage
Charter party considerations and unloading
4.161
Independent obligations and indemnities
4.162
Penalty clauses
4.163
Independent obligation example
4.164
High charter party rates
4.165
Commencement of demurrage
4.166
Incorporation and time charter parties
4.167
Incorporation and interpretation
4.168
Charter party independent of sale
4.169
Incorporating charter party terms
Incorporating charter party terms
4.170
Unloading the goods
Costs
4.171
Charter parties and discharge costs
4.172
Congestion
4.173
Duty to unload in berth
4.174
Interruption of unloading
4.175
5 Licences and Impossibility
Preliminary Material
A Introduction
5.01
B Applying for Export and Import Licences
General
Customs clearance and duties
5.02
Licences
5.03
Principal questions
5.04
Identifying the applicant: general
Incoterms
5.05
Express identification
5.06
Identifying the applicant: FOB
Buyer bound to apply
5.07
FAS contract
5.08
Seller bound to apply
5.09
Alternative destination
5.10
Buyer’s export plans
5.11
Justification
5.12
Identifying the applicant: CIF
General
5.13
Passing of property
5.14
C Guaranteed Procurement or Due Diligence to Procure?
Strictness of duty
Various formulations
5.15
Presumptive rule
5.16
Criticism
5.17
Contrary intention
5.18
Strict duty where force majeure excluded
5.19
Strict duty where impossibility defence
5.20
Summary
5.21
Incoterms 2010
5.22
Self-induced impossibility
5.23
Due diligence in fact
Inactive applicant
5.24
Co-operation of other party
5.25
Difficulties facing applicant
5.26
Continuing duty to apply
5.27
Futile efforts
5.28
Third party applicants
5.29
Burden of proof
5.30
Refusal of licence
Effect of refusal
5.31
Liability for failure to obtain licence
5.32
D Initial Impossibility (Mistake)
Specific goods
5.33
Contractual defence or discharge?
5.34
Commodity sales
5.35
Lost cargoes
5.36
E Subsequent Impossibility (Frustration)
General
Unascertained goods
5.37
Goods intended by seller
5.38
Precautions
5.39
Place of shipment implied
5.40
Risk
5.41
Carriage route
5.42
Frustration and payment
5.43
Impossibility in fact
5.44
Frustration and governmental intervention
General
5.45
Commercial governmental action
5.46
Failure of supplier
5.47
Attribution
5.48
Express clauses
5.49
Governmental prohibition and restriction of export
5.50
Nature of act
5.51
Causal impact
5.52
The GAFTA prevention clause
5.53
Effect of force majeure clauses
5.54
Licences, due diligence, and express clauses
Prohibition and unprofitability
5.55
Selling monopolies
5.56
Licences, strict duties, and express clauses
Strict duty and defences
5.57
Contractual construction
5.58
Obtaining and maintaining licence
5.59
Strict and absolute
5.60
CIF contracts and import controls
Frustration
5.61
No implied term
5.62
Joint venture and sale
5.63
Territorial scope of legislation
5.64
The Mississippi disaster: a cautionary tale
The Mississippi floods 1973
5.65
The events
5.66
Market effect
5.67
Government intervention
5.68
Force majeure
Force majeure and the shipper
5.69
Suspension and prevention
5.70
Other force majeure points
5.71
Prohibition of export
Prevailing clause
5.72
Prevention not delay
5.73
Tracing back
5.74
Partial prohibition and allocation
5.75
Later prohibition clauses
5.76
Illegality by the law of the place of performance
Supervening illegality under foreign law
5.77
Implied term
5.78
Special clause
5.79
Illegality and frustration
5.80
Separate principles
5.81
Promisor’s residence
5.82
The Rome Convention and Rome I Regulation
General
5.83
Domestic law or conflict of laws?
5.84
6 Payment
Preliminary Material
A Introduction
Payment methods and systems
General
6.01
Domestic and international sales
6.02
Payment rules
Place of payment
6.03
Method of payment
6.04
The seller’s risk
6.05
Seller’s assurance
6.06
Bank drafts
6.07
Time of the essence
6.08
Time and international sales
6.09
B Negotiable Instruments
Bills of exchange
6.10
Liability and negotiation
6.11
Example
6.12
Negotiating the bill
6.13
Draft bills of exchange and bills of lading
6.14
Promissory notes
6.15
Forfaiting
6.16
C Bank Collections and Letters of Credit
Bank collections
Types of collection
6.17
Uniform collection rules
6.18
Documentary collections
6.19
Collection and payment
6.20
Letters of credit: introduction
Uniform rules
6.21
Compatibility of UCP rules and the letter of credit
6.22
Example
6.23
Operating the credit
6.24
Negotiation credits
6.25
Irrevocable credits
6.26
Payment under the credit
6.27
Standby credits and similar instruments
6.28
Autonomy of credit: introduction
6.29
Opening the letter of credit
Binding character of letters of credit
6.30
Meaning of opening a credit
6.31
Date of bank’s commitment to beneficiary
6.32
Conditions precedent to opening the letter of credit
6.33
Buyer’s liability for failure to open a credit
6.34
Precondition to delivery
6.35
Timely opening of credit by buyer
No specific date
6.36
‘Within a few weeks’
6.37
Construction issue
6.38
No stated date: CIF contracts
Introduction
6.39
Other considerations
6.40
Pre-shipment
6.41
Reasonable time before shipment
6.42
No stated date: FOB contracts
Introduction
6.43
Throughout the shipment period
6.44
Certainty and sales strings
6.45
Supporting authority
6.46
Waiving delay in opening a letter of credit
Waiver and variation
6.47
Retracting waiver
6.48
Presentation and documentary compliance
Date of presentation
6.49
Strictness of documentary compliance
6.50
UCP rules and strict compliance
6.51
Description
6.52
Documentary consistency
6.53
Examples of non-compliance
6.54
Further example
6.55
Omissions
6.56
Photocopies and reprographic documents I
6.57
Photocopies and reprographic documents II
6.58
Photocopies and reprographic documents III: UCP 600
6.59
Curing deficiencies in the letter of credit
6.60
Examination and rejection
Apparent compliance
6.61
Notification of discrepancies and rejection
6.62
Payment
General
6.63
Payment and examination
6.64
UCP 500 and the time allowed for examination
6.65
UCP 600 and the time allowed for examination
6.66
Payment under reserve
6.67
Default by bank
6.68
Damages
6.69
Letter of credit and sale contract
General
6.70
Parallel documentary requirements
6.71
Sale qualified by credit
6.72
Effect of credit on sale
6.73
Forbearance
6.74
Variation
6.75
Absolute or conditional payment?
6.76
Autonomy, fraud, and related matters
Introduction
6.77
Defences to payment
6.78
False statements
6.79
Forged documents
6.80
Documentary nullities
6.81
The Montrod case
6.82
The illegality exception
6.83
The decision of the court in Mahonia
6.84
The fraud exception to payment
6.85
Legal basis of fraud exception
6.86
Injunctions sought by applicant
6.87
Bank resisting payment
6.88
Beneficiary’s fraud and knowledge of fraud
6.89
Fraud and the UN Convention
6.90
Applicable law: general
6.91
Pre-Rome Convention cases
6.92
Applicable law of unconfirmed credit pre-Rome
6.93
Connected contracts and infection
6.94
7 Passing of Property and Risk
Preliminary Material
A Passing of Property
Introduction
No express duty to pass property
7.01
Contractual significance of property
7.02
Insolvency
7.03
Actions against carriers
7.04
Passing of property rules
Role of intention
7.05
Presumptive intention: specific goods
7.06
Presumptive intention: unascertained goods
7.07
FOB contracts
On board
7.08
Delivery of the goods
7.09
Payment before loading
7.10
CIF contracts
Payment against shipping documents
7.11
Ascertainment
Meaning of ascertainment
7.12
Act not promise
7.13
Notices of appropriation
7.14
Presence of the carrier
7.15
Bulk goods
Precise ascertainment
7.16
Commodity sales
7.17
No equitable right
7.18
Further equitable considerations
7.19
Tenancy in common
7.20
Non-physical ascertainment of goods
7.21
Commodity sales
7.22
De facto ascertainment
7.23
Sections 20A–20B of the Sale of Goods Act
Introduction
7.24
Undivided share in bulk
7.25
Different holds
7.26
Buyer’s proportional interest
7.27
Payment
7.28
Goods ascertained
7.29
Shrinkage problems I
7.30
Shrinkage problems II
7.31
Deliveries from a shrunken bulk
7.32
Standard form contract provisions
Example
7.33
Conflict of laws and bulks
7.34
Passing of property and the carrier
Former position
7.35
Non-bulk difficulties
7.36
B Reserving the Right of Disposal
General
Introduction
7.37
Occurrence of reservation
Form of reservation
7.38
Strength of presumption
7.39
FOB and CIF differences
7.40
Proprietary effect of reservation
Nature of reservation
7.41
Variable circumstances
7.42
Releasing the right
7.43
Situs rule
7.44
Draft bill of exchange and bill of lading
Effect on property
7.45
Acceptance and payment of bill of exchange
7.46
C Transfer of Risk
Meaning of risk
Property and contract
7.47
Risk and property
7.48
Risk and FOB contracts
Presumptive rule
7.49
Time of shipment
7.50
A delivery test
7.51
Incremental transfer of risk
7.52
Oil deliveries
7.53
Notice of shipment
7.54
Reasonable contract of carriage
General
7.55
Effect of sub-section 32(2)
7.56
Risk and CIF contracts
Retrospective risk transfer
7.57
Risk and the CISG
7.58
Bulk CIF goods and the CISG
7.59
Divided risk
7.60
Carriage ‘on behalf’ of buyer
7.61
Pre-shipment insurance
7.62
Quality and fitness and damage in transit
Risk and quality obligations
7.63
Reasonable period
7.64
D Retrospective Appropriation of Lost Cargoes
Specific goods
7.65
Unascertained goods: introduction
7.66
Varied circumstances
7.67
Pre-tender loss
7.68
Pre-appropriation loss
7.69
The seller’s position
7.70
Seller’s knowledge
7.71
Trade custom
7.72
Insurance policy
7.73
8 Bills of Lading and Documents of Title
Preliminary Material
A The Buyer and the Carrier
Privity of contract
Introduction
8.01
Contracts (Rights of Third Parties) Act 1999
8.02
Bill of lading as document of title
8.03
Benefit of carriage contract
8.04
Problems with the Bills of Lading Act 1855
Restricted application to modern shipping
8.05
Non-statutory avenues
8.06
Bulk shipments
8.07
Date of the passing of property
8.08
Property passing after transfer
8.09
Implied contracts
The Brandt v Liverpool contract
8.10
Equivocal conduct
8.11
No contract implied
8.12
Co-operation insufficient
8.13
Other devices
Assignment and bailment
8.14
Detinue
8.15
Untried possibility
8.16
The Carriage of Goods by Sea Act 1992: documents
Holders of bills of lading
8.17
Other holders
8.18
Agency
8.19
Sea waybills
8.20
Straight (non-negotiable) bills of lading
8.21
Ship’s delivery orders
8.22
Transferred rights
8.23
’Excluded parties
8.24
Exhausted bill of lading
8.25
Different conclusion
8.26
Rejection of goods or documents
8.27
The Carriage of Goods by Sea Act 1992: the shipper
No rights of suit
8.28
The rule in Dunlop v Lambert
8.29
Modern summary
8.30
Prior and intermediate parties: bills of lading
8.31
Prior and intermediate parties: sea waybills
8.32
Prior and intermediate parties: ship’s delivery orders
8.33
The Carriage of Goods by Sea Act 1992: the carrier’s rights
Carrier’s rights separated from liabilities
8.34
Partial liability
8.35
Liabilities of bills of lading holders
8.36
Bearer bills and liabilities
8.37
Liabilities and demanding delivery
8.38
Liabilities and making a claim
8.39
Implied term in bill of lading contract
8.40
HagueVisby Rules
8.41
Intermediate holder and divesting of liabilities
8.42
Delivery demands and actual delivery
8.43
Liabilities of original contracting party
8.44
B Bill of Lading as Document of Title
Documents of title
On board bill of lading
8.45
Straight bills of lading as documents of title
8.46
Bills of lading and the passing of property
8.47
Constructive delivery
8.48
The bill of lading and delivery by the carrier
8.49
Defective title of holder
8.50
Lost bill of lading
8.51
Charter parties
8.52
Bills of lading in sets
Risk of fraud
8.53
Carrier’s protection
8.54
Multiple bills in circulation
8.55
Exhaustion of the bill of lading
Release of goods
8.56
Contrary view
8.57
Warehousing of goods
8.58
Unilateral contracts and attornment
Standing offer by carrier?
8.59
Attornment
8.60
C Evidentiary Function of Bills of Lading
General
Statements in bill of lading
8.61
Common law and Hague–Visby Rules
8.62
Statements about quantity in the bill of lading
Common law position
8.63
Burden of proof and quantity
8.64
Modern position
8.65
Carrier’s limited duty
8.66
Statements about condition in the bill of lading
Limited range of statements
8.67
External condition
8.68
Added wording
8.69
Statements about leading marks in the bill of lading
Description
8.70
Statements by the master
8.71
Hague–Visby Rules
8.72
Other statements in the bill of lading
Common law
8.73
Bill of lading as evidence of the contract of carriage
Evidence and contract itself distinguished
8.74
Carrier and indorsee
8.75
Indorsement to charterer
8.76
D Bills of Lading: Other Matters
Negotiation of the bill
Process of negotiation
8.77
Rights transferred
8.78
Prima facie evidence of property passing
8.79
Received for shipment bills of lading
Introduction
8.80
The authorities
8.81
Null bills of lading
8.82
E Other Shipping Documents
Mate’s receipts
A simple receipt
8.83
Local custom
8.84
Warrants and orders
Delivery warrant
8.85
Delivery order
8.86
F Non-Negotiable Documents and the Power to Transfer Title
Title disputes
8.87
Estoppel
8.88
Statutory exceptions: general
8.89
Extended meaning of ‘document of title’
8.90
Conflict of laws
8.91
Dispersed transaction
8.92
Buyer in possession
8.93
Non-ascertainment
8.94
Unpaid seller’s real rights
Lien
8.95
Stoppage in transit
8.96
Assenting to sub-sales
8.97
G Alternatives to the Paper Bill of Lading
Introduction
8.98
Alternatives to moving paper
8.99
Functions of the bill of lading
8.100
SeaDocs
8.101
The BOLERO system
8.102
8.103
essDocs
8.104
9 Remedies: Termination and Damages
Preliminary Material
A Termination of the Contract
Introduction
9.01
Termination
Meaning of termination
9.02
Conditions and innominate terms
9.03
Loss of rejection right
9.04
Twin rejection rights
9.05
Loss of the right of termination
Waiver and election
9.06
Affirmation and acceptance
9.07
Acceptance and examination
9.08
Deferring examination
9.09
Examination and time
9.10
Rejection and acceptance
General
9.11
Act inconsistent with seller’s ownership
9.12
Retention beyond reasonable time
9.13
Commencement of time
9.14
Arrival of the goods
9.15
Buyer’s retention of goods
9.16
Waiving the right to reject the goods
Dealings with the documents
9.17
Finding of fact
9.18
Scope of Panchaud principle
9.19
Estoppel by conduct
9.20
Waiver and damages
9.21
B The Integrity of the Documentary Exchange
Dual rights of rejection
General
9.22
Separate breaches
9.23
Example
9.24
Conforming documents and non-conforming goods
9.25
Conforming documents and future physical breaches
CIF buyer’s commercial risk
9.26
The Braithwaite problem
9.27
Landing inspector’s certificate
9.28
Australian authority
9.29
Non-conforming documents
9.30
False statements
9.31
Evidence of non-conformity?
9.32
Conclusion
9.33
Letter of credit
9.34
Discounting the seller’s damages
Buyer’s future damages
9.35
Restoring the seller
9.36
The immediate damages principle and resolved contingencies
9.37
Extension to sale
9.38
The immediate damages principle and pending contingencies
9.39
Damages against the prematurely repudiating CIF buyer
9.40
Nominal damages?
9.41
C Damages
Common law damages rules
General
9.42
Uncertainty and reliance damages
9.43
Causation in fact and remoteness of damage
9.44
Mitigation
9.45
Agreed damages
9.46
The market rule in international sales
Introduction
9.47
The market rule
9.48
Meaning of ‘market’
9.49
Substitute transaction not required
9.50
Arranging substitute transaction
9.51
Flexibility
9.52
Breach date rule
9.53
Last performance date
9.54
Contractual discretion
9.55
Sub-sales, resales and cover purchases
General
9.56
Example
9.57
Contractual advantage
9.58
Exceptional cases
9.59
Late delivery
9.60
Defective goods
9.61
Anticipatory repudiation
Introduction
9.62
Even-handed rule
9.63
The mitigation date
9.64
Mitigating in the futures market
9.65
No stated delivery date
9.66
Refusal date rule
9.67
Pre-delivery obligations
Notices predating performance
9.68
A difficult case
9.69
Notices and the breach date
9.70
Time needed to mitigate
9.71
FOB cases
9.72
CIF oil contracts
9.73
Difficulties with the market rule in commodities cases
General
9.74
Spot market transactions
9.75
Sub-sale exception
9.76
Sub-sale settlements
9.77
Anticipated profits
9.78
Similar commodity markets
9.79
D Excluding the Sale of Goods Act Rules
Default clauses: general
Introduction and FOSFA contracts
9.80
GAFTA contracts
9.81
Default clauses and options
9.82
Date of default
Establishing the date for particular breaches
9.83
Default and FOB contracts
9.84
Expected readiness to load
9.85
CIF seller’s default
9.86
Construing the default clause
9.87
Postponing default
9.88
Calculating amounts due under default clauses
Valuing the goods
9.89
Location of goods
9.90
Default clauses and sub-sales
9.91
Default and optional quantities
9.92
Consequential damages and other remedies
9.93
Charter party losses
9.94
Default and invoicing back
9.95
Non-breach settlements
Introduction
9.96
Circle clauses
9.97
Example
9.98
Establishing the circle
9.99
Insolvency clauses
9.100
Selecting the appropriate clause
9.101
Preferred approach
9.102
Other financial settlements
9.103
E The Twin Rights of Rejection and the Seller’s Damages Liability
Damages and termination
Introduction
9.104
Allocating risk
9.105
Effect of termination on risk allocation
9.106
Damages claims and market risk
9.107
Damages and the twin rejection rights
Introduction
9.108
Delivery orders
9.109
Cause of buyer’s loss
9.110
No documentary breach?
9.111
Bills of lading
9.112
Causing loss
9.113
Reversing market decline
9.114
Extending the Finlay principle
9.115
Departure from orthodoxy
9.116
Agreement reserving rights
9.117
Buyers’ equivocal behaviour
9.118
Mandatory rejection rules
9.119
Rejecting later documents
9.120
Defective documents
9.121
No concealment of termination rights
9.122
Concealment of documentary breach?
9.123
Documentary breach
9.124
Rejecting the documents
9.125
Confining Finlay damages to fraud?
9.126
Criticism
9.127
Part II International Sales Governed by the UN Sale Convention 1980 (CISG)
Preliminary Material
10 The UN Sale Convention (CISG): General Issues
Preliminary Material
A Introduction
The CISG as uniform law
10.01
Example
10.02
Merits and drawbacks of uniform law
10.03
Position of the UK
10.04
UK merchants and the CISG
10.05
B Background to the CISG
Early developments
10.06
The Hague Conventions and the UK
10.07
UNCITRAL
10.08
Participants in the uniformity process
10.09
C Sphere of Application
Different places of business
10.10
Article 1(1)(a) and private international law considerations
10.11
Article 1(1)(b) and private international law
10.12
ULIS
10.13
The CISG and other international conventions
10.14
Rome Convention
10.15
The Rome I Regulation
10.16
D Field of Operation
Sale of goods contracts
10.17
Goods
10.18
Buyer supplies materials
10.19
Other labour and material contracts
10.20
Price and barter
10.21
Framework contracts
10.22
Finance leases and hire purchase
10.23
Tort
10.24
Derivative claims
10.25
Death and personal injury
10.26
Whose death or personal injury?
10.27
E Exclusions
General
10.28
Property
10.29
Property and contractual avoidance
10.30
Validity
10.31
Exclusion clauses
10.32
Penalty clauses
10.33
Contractual vitiating factors
10.34
Validity and Unidroit Principles
10.35
F Role of Unidroit Principles
Supporting general law
10.36
Legitimacy of Unidroit Principles
10.37
Arbitration proceedings
10.38
Judicial proceedings
10.39
G Interpretation and Good Faith
General
10.40
National attitudes
10.41
Good faith
10.42
Excluding good faith
10.43
H Filling Gaps in the Coverage of the CISG
General
10.44
Example
10.45
Discovering general principles
10.46
Examples of general principles
10.47
Penalty clauses
10.48
Contrary reasoning
10.49
10.50
Private international law
10.51
I Excluding and Varying the CISG
Express and implied exclusion
10.52
Exclusion and choice of law clauses
10.53
Opting directly into the CISG
10.54
J Reservations
Reservations and declarations
10.55
Article 95
10.56
Example
10.57
Declarations and reservations under treaty law
10.58
The Article 96 declaration
10.59
Response of courts of non-declaring State
10.60
K Usages and Practices
General
10.61
Established practices
10.62
Usages and Incoterms
10.63
Shipping terms
10.64
L Limitations
General
10.65
11 Formation and Performance of the Contract
Preliminary Material
A Formation of the Contract
Introduction
11.01
Meaning of formation
11.02
Formation rules
11.03
Keeping the offer open
11.04
Effect of revoking irrevocable offer
11.05
Acceptance of the offer
11.06
Form of acceptance
11.07
Late acceptances
11.08
‘Reach’
11.09
Mirror image acceptance
11.10
Battle of forms
11.11
Certainty and the price
11.12
Binding offers
11.13
No price machinery
11.14
11.15
B Interpretation and Contents of the Contract
General
11.16
Formalities
11.17
Incorporation of standard terms I
11.18
Incorporation of standard terms II
11.19
Incorporation of statements
11.20
Parol evidence rule
11.21
Merger clauses
11.22
Interpreting the contract
11.23
Controlling amendments
11.24
C Conformity of the Goods
General
11.25
Description
11.26
Reliance and description
11.27
Imposed quality obligations
11.28
Reliance and strict liability
11.29
Strictness of liability
11.30
Fitness for all ordinary purposes
11.31
Variable standard
11.32
The role of the buyer: examination
11.33
The role of the buyer: contributory negligence
11.34
Misrepresentation
11.35
Misrepresentation and the CISG
11.36
Misrepresentation and validity
11.37
Quality, fitness and risk
11.38
Industrial and intellectual property claims
11.39
Other third party claims
11.40
Examination and notice
11.41
Notice requirements
11.42
Effect of non-compliance
11.43
D Delivery and Payment
General
11.44
Place, meaning and time of delivery
11.45
Carriage responsibilities
11.46
Buyer’s duties
11.47
Concurrency
11.48
12 Remedies for Breach of Contract
Preliminary Material
A Remedies
General
12.01
B Avoidance for Non-Performance
Avoidance: general
12.02
Strict performance and international sales
12.03
Fundamental breach
12.04
Commodities, documents and time
12.05
Foresight
12.06
Time of foresight
12.07
Perfect tender?
12.08
Buyer’s duty to take delivery
12.09
Anticipatory non-performance and suspension
12.10
Making time of the essence
12.11
Effect of notice
12.12
Timing of notice
12.13
English law
12.14
Instalment contracts
12.15
C Anticipatory Breach and Suspension
Suspension
12.16
Anticipatory repudiation
12.17
Present and anticipatory breach
12.18
Adequate assurance
12.19
Adequate assurance and English law
12.20
D Cure and Loss of Avoidance Rights
Introduction
12.21
Curing defective performance
12.22
Cure before and after delivery date
12.23
Type of cure
12.24
Further complications in Article 48
12.25
Cost of cure
12.26
Lateness
12.27
Cure and avoidance
12.28
Quality of cure
12.29
Notice of defect and cure
12.30
Loss of the right of avoidance in English law
12.31
Loss of the right of avoidance under the CISG
12.32
Ability to make restitution
12.33
Other bars on avoidance
12.34
E Consequences of Avoidance
General
12.35
Primary restitution
12.36
Concurrency
12.37
Reversed sale example
12.38
Cost of restitution
12.39
Risk
12.40
Benefits and interest: general
12.41
Period of interest accrual
12.42
Rate of interest
12.43
Currency of interest
12.44
Buyer’s benefit
12.45
Preservation of the goods
12.46
F Direct Enforcement
Requiring performance and specific performance
12.47
Specific performance mentioned
12.48
G Money Claims
Price reduction
12.49
Example: falling market
12.50
Example: rising market
12.51
Relationship to damages rule
12.52
Damages rules
12.53
Damages and probability of loss
12.54
Full compensation
12.55
Extensive liability
12.56
Reliance and expectation
12.57
The nature of a reliance claim
12.58
Certainty and loss of a chance
12.59
Penalties and liquidated damages
12.60
Non-delivery and non-acceptance
12.61
Current price
12.62
Interest
12.63
Interest on damages
12.64
Mitigation
12.65
Mitigation and requiring performance
12.66
H Exemption from Liability
Exemptions: structure
12.67
Effect on remainder of contract
12.68
Exemptions and defective goods
12.69
Nature of impediment
12.70
Delegated performance
12.71
Hardship
12.72
Initial impossibility
12.73
Further Material
Appendix 1 GAFTA Contract 100
Appendix 2 GAFTA Contract 119
Appendix 3 FOSFA Contract 24
Appendix 4 FOSFA Contract 53
Appendix 5 United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods 1980
Part I Sphere of application and general provisions
Ch.1 Sphere of Application
Article 1
Article 2
Article 3
Article 4
Article 5
Article 6
Ch.II General Provisions
Article 7
Article 8
Article 9
Article 10
Article 11
Article 12
Article 13
Part II Formation of the contract
Article 14
Article 15
Article 16
Article 17
Article 18
Article 19
Article 20
Article 21
Article 22
Article 23
Article 24
Part III Sale of goods
Ch.I General Provisions
Article 25
Article 26
Article 27
Article 28
Article 29
Ch.II Obligations of The Seller
Article 30
s.I Delivery of the goods and handing over of documents
Article 31
Article 32
Article 33
Article 34
s.II Conformity of the goods and third party claims
Article 35
Article 36
Article 37
Article 38
Article 39
Article 40
Article 41
Article 42
Article 43
Article 44
s.III Remedies for breach of contract by the seller
Article 45
Article 46
Article 47
Article 48
Article 49
Article 50
Article 51
Article 52
Ch.III Obligations of The Buyer
Article 53
s.I Payment of the price
Article 54
Article 55
Article 56
Article 57
Article 58
Article 59
s.II Taking delivery
Article 60
s.III Remedies for breach of contract by the buyer
Article 61
Article 62
Article 63
Article 64
Article 65
Ch.IV Passing of Risk
Article 66
Article 67
Article 68
Article 69
Article 70
Ch.V Provisions Common to The Obligations of The Seller and of The Buyer
s.I Anticipatory Breach and Instalment Contracts
Article 71
Article 72
Article 73
Section II
Damages
Article 74
Article 75
Article 76
Article 77
Section III
Interest
Article 78
Section IV
Exemption
Article 79
Article 80
Section V
Effects of avoidance
Article 81
Article 82
Article 83
Article 84
Section VI
Preservation of the goods
Article 85
Article 86
Article 87
Article 88
Part IV
Final Provisions
Article 89
Article 90
Article 91
Article 92
Article 93
Article 94
Article 95
Article 96
Article 97
Article 98
Article 99
Article 100
Article 101
Appendix 6 ICC Uniform Customs and Practice for Documentary Credits (UCP 600) (2007 Revision)
Article 1
Application of UCP
Article 2
Definitions
Article 3
InterpretationsFor the purpose of these rules:
Article 4
Credits v. Contracts
a
b
Article 5
Documents v. Goods, Services or Performance
Article 6
Availability, Expiry Date and Place for Presentation
Article 7
Issuing Bank Undertaking
Article 8
Confirming Bank Undertaking
Article 9
Article 10
Amendments
Article 11
Teletransmitted and Pre-Advised Credits and Amendments
Article 12
Nomination
Article 13
Bank-to-Bank Reimbursement Arrangements
Article 14
Standard for Examination of Documents
Article 15
Complying Presentation
Article 16
Discrepant Documents, Waiver and Notice
Article 17
Original Documents and Copies
Article 18
Commercial Invoice
Article 19
Transport Document Covering at Least Two Different Modes of Transport
Article 20
Bill of Lading
Article 21
Non-Negotiable Sea Waybill
Article 22
Charter Party Bill of Lading
Article 23
Air Transport Document
Article 24
Road, Rail or Inland Waterway Transport Documents
Article 25
Courier Receipt, Post Receipt or Certificate of Posting
Article 26
“On Deck”, “Shipper’s Load and Count”, “Said by Shipper to Contain” and Charges Additional to Freight
Article 27
Clean Transport Document
Article 28
Insurance Document and Coverage
Article 29
Extension of Expiry Date or Last Day for Presentation
Article 30
Tolerance in Credit Amount, Quantity and Unit Prices
Article 31
Partial Drawings or Shipments
Article 32
Instalment Drawings or Shipments
Article 33
Hours of Presentation
Article 34
Disclaimer on Effectiveness of Documents
Article 35
Disclaimer on Transmission and Translation
Article 36
Force Majeure
Article 37
Disclaimer for Acts of an Instructed Party
Article 38
Transferable Credits
Article 39
Assignment of Proceeds
Appendix 7 Free on Board
FOB (insert named port of shipment) Incoterms® 2010
Appendix 8 Cost Insurance and Freight
CIF (insert named port of destination) Incoterms® 2010
Appendix 9 Sale of Goods Act 1979 (as amended)
Sale of Goods Act 1979
1979 Chapter 54
Part I
Contracts To Which Act Applies
Part II
Formation Of The Contract
Contract of sale
Formalities of contract
Subject matter of contract
The price
[F4Implied terms etc.]
Sale by sample
[F25Miscellaneous]
Part III
Effects Of The Contract
Transfer of property as between seller and buyer
Transfer of title
Part IV
Performance Of The Contract
Part V
Rights Of Unpaid Seller Against The Goods
Preliminary
Unpaid seller’s lien
Stoppage in transit
Re-sale etc. by buyer
Rescission: and re-sale by seller
F60Part 5A
Additional Rights Of Buyer In Consumer Cases
Part VI
Actions For Breach Of The Contract
Seller’s remedies
Buyer’s remedies
Interest, etc.
Part VII
Supplementary
Schedules
Sch.1 Section 1Modification Of Act For Certain Contracts
Preliminary
Section 11: condition treated as warranty
Section 12: implied terms about title etc.
Section 13: sale by description
Section 14: quality or fitness (i)
Section 14: quality or fitness (ii)
Section 15: sale by sample
Section 22: market overt
Section 25: buyer in possession
Section 35: acceptance
Section 55: exclusion of implied terms (ii)
Section 56: conflict of laws
Section 61(1): definition of “business” (i)
Section 61(1): definition of “business” (ii)
Law Reform (Frustrated Contracts) Act 1943 (6 & 7 Geo. 6 c. 40)
Frustrated Contracts Act (Northern Ireland) 1947 (c. 2)
Hire-Purchase Act 1964 (c. 53)
Hire-Purchase Act 1965 (c. 66)
Hire-Purchase (Scotland) Act 1965 (c. 67)
Hire-Purchase Act (Northern Ireland) 1966 (c. 42)
Uniform Laws on International Sales Act 1967 (c. 45)
Supply of Goods (Implied Terms) Act 1973 (c. 13)
Consumer Credit Act 1974 (c. 39)
Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977 (c. 50)
Appendix 10 Carriage of Goods by Sea Act 1992
(C. 50)
1992 Chapter C. 50
1.—
2.—
3.—
(1)
4
5.—
6.—
(1)
Glossary
Index
Sign up for alerts
Index
From:
The International Sale of Goods (4th Edition)
Michael Bridge
Previous Edition (3 ed.)
Content type:
Book content
Product:
International Commercial Law [ICML]
Published in print:
30 November 2017
ISBN:
9780198792703
Prev
|
Next
[3.239.242.55]
3.239.242.55