We use cookies to enhance your experience on our website. By continuing to use our website, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. You can change your cookie settings at any time.
Find out more
Jump to Content
Jump to Main Navigation
User Account
Personal Profile
See all online law products
More
About
Guided Tour
Subscriber Services
Contact Us
FAQ
Help
Search
Advanced Search
Browse all
Area of law
Financial Law [FBL]
International Commercial Arbitration [ICMA]
Private International Law [PRIL]
International Commercial Law [ICML]
Author
My Content
(0)
Recently viewed
(0)
Save Entry
My Searches
(0)
Recently viewed
(0)
Save Search
Print
Save
Cite
Email this content
Share Link
Copy this link, or click below to email it to a friend
Email this content
or copy the link directly:
https://olrl.ouplaw.com/display/10.1093/law/9780198869726.001.0001/law-9780198869726-chapter-7
The link was not copied. Your current browser may not support copying via this button.
Link copied successfully
Copy link
Signed in as:
Access is brought to you by
Sign in to an additional subscriber account
This account has no valid subscription for this site.
You could not be signed in, please check and try again.
Username
Please enter your Username
Password
Please enter your Password
Forgot password?
Don't have an account?
Sign in via your Institution
You could not be signed in, please check and try again.
Sign in with your library card
Please enter your library card number
View translated passages only
Oxford Law Citator
Contents
Expand All
Collapse All
Preliminary Material
Preface
Contents—Summary
Contents
Later Developments
Smart Meter Communication Licensee Administration
Gibraltarian Insurers
Gibraltarian Credit Institutions
Circumstances in which a Winding-up Order may be Made
2.26
Remote Hearing
5.02A
Notice of Appearance
5.34
Foreign Judgments (Reciprocal Enforcement) Act 1933
7.394
The Just and Equitable Clause
8.139
Petitioner’s Contribution to the Situation
8.250
Deadlock
8.281A
Part A1 Moratorium
10.04
Table of Cases
Table of Legislation
Australia (see also New South Wales, Western Australia)
Belgium
British Columbia
Canada (see also British Columbia, Manitoba, Ontario)
Cayman Islands
Gibraltar
Hong Kong
Isle of Man
Malaysia
Manitoba
New South Wales
New Zealand
Nova Scotia
Ontario
Scotland
Singapore
United Kingdom
Virgin Islands Insolvency Act
Western Australia
Table of UK Statutory Instruments
Table of European Legislation
Decisions
Directives
Primary Law
Regulations
Table of International Treaties and Conventions
List of Abbreviations
Main Text
1 Jurisdiction, Sources and General Rules
Preliminary Material
Nature and Purpose of Compulsory Winding Up
Proceedings for Winding Up by the Court
1.01
1.02
1.03
1.04
1.05
Bank Insolvency and Building Society Insolvency
1.06
Compulsory and Voluntary Winding Up
1.07
1.08
1.09
Purposes of Compulsory Winding Up
Principal purposes
1.10
1.11
1.12
1.13
1.14
1.15
Liquidator
1.16
1.17
1.18
1.19
1.20
Objectives of bank and building society insolvency
1.21
Investigation of the company’s affairs
1.22
1.23
1.24
1.25
Process of Winding Up
1.26
1.27
Dissolution
1.28
1.29
1.30
1.31
1.32
Death
1.33
1.34
Winding Up a Company and Winding Up its Affairs or Business
1.35
1.36
Winding Up through Administration
Introduction
1.37
Schedule B1 administration
1.38
1.39
1.40
1.41
Sources of the Law on Winding Up Companies
Current Legislation
1.42
Insolvency Act 1986 (IA 1986)
1.43
1.44
1.45
1.46
1.47
Insolvent Partnerships Order 1994 (IPO 1994)
1.48
1.49
1.50
1.51
Banking Act 2009
1.52
Insolvency (England and Wales) Rules 2016 (IR 2016)
1.53
1.54
1.55
1.56
Application of IR 2016
1.57
1.58
1.59
Continuing effect of IR 1986
1.60
Bank Insolvency (England and Wales) Rules 2009 and Building Society Insolvency (England and Wales) Rules 2010
1.61
Civil Procedure Rules 1998 (CPR)
1.62
1.63
1.64
Practice Direction — Insolvency Proceedings (IPD)
1.65
UNCITRAL Model Law
1.66
1.67
1.68
1.69
Regulation (EU) 2015/848
1.70
References in this work to legislation
1.71
Case Law and Interpretation of Legislation
1.72
1.73
1.74
1.75
Law of other Jurisdictions
1.76
1.77
Entities which may be Wound Up: Introduction
1.78
1.79
1.80
1.81
1.82
1.83
Centre of Main Interests and Establishment
Centre of main interests
1.84
1.85
1.86
1.87
1.88
1.89
1.90
1.91
1.92
1.93
Establishment
1.94
1.95
1.96
Registered Companies
Companies Registered in England and Wales
1.97
1.98
Meaning of ‘Company Registered under the Companies Act 2006’
UK-registered companies
1.99
Companies formed and registered under Companies Acts since 1856
1.100
1.101
1.102
1.103
1.104
1.105
1.106
1.107
1.108
1.109
Companies registered, but not formed, under Companies Acts since 1856
1.110
1.111
1.112
1.113
1.114
Dissolved Registered Companies
1.115
1.116
Validity of Registration
1.117
1.118
1.119
1.120
Effect of Events outside the Jurisdiction
Business outside the jurisdiction
1.121
Registered office outside the jurisdiction
1.122
COMI in an EU State
1.123
COMI elsewhere
1.124
Winding up outside the jurisdiction
1.125
Registered Companies which are Members of Insolvent Partnerships (‘Corporate Members’)
1.126
1.127
1.128
1.129
1.130
Entities Treated as Registered Companies
Building Societies
1.131
1.132
Charitable Incorporated Organizations
1.133
European Public Limited-Liability Companies / UK Societates
1.134
Further Education Bodies that are Statutory Corporations
1.135
Incorporated Friendly Societies
1.136
Limited Liability Partnerships
1.137
Registered Societies
1.138
1.139
1.140
Unregistered Companies
What is an Unregistered Company?
Statutory definition
1.141
1.142
1.143
1.144
Time at which status must be determined
1.145
1.146
Unregistered companies which are to be wound up under IA 1986, part 4
1.147
Examples of Unregistered Companies which may be Wound Up under IA 1986, Part 5
1.148
1.149
Insolvent Partnerships and Financial Services Partnerships
Types of petition against insolvent partnerships
1.150
1.151
Application and modification of IA 1986 and IR 2016
1.152
1.153
1.154
1.155
1.156
Connection with the jurisdiction
1.157
1.158
1.159
1.160
Definition of ‘insolvent partnership’
1.161
Limited partnerships
1.162
Limited liability partnerships
1.163
Financial services partnerships
1.164
Administration of joint estate as if a winding-up order had been made
1.165
Court orders to wind up an insolvent partnership other than as an unregistered company
1.166
Winding up in bankruptcy on members’ petition
1.167
Winding up in bankruptcy by direction of the court
1.168
Orders under the Partnership Act 1890, s 39
1.169
Winding up business and affairs
1.170
1.171
Receiver of partnership property
1.172
Dissolution
1.173
1.174
Other Entities Identified in Legislation as Unregistered Companies
European/UK economic interest groupings
1.175
1.176
Collective investment schemes
1.177
1.178
1.179
Protected cell companies
1.180
COMI in the United Kingdom
1.181
1.182
1.183
1.184
1.185
1.186
Foreign Companies
Foreign companies as unregistered companies
1.187
1.188
Conditions for winding up a foreign company
1.189
Jurisdiction or discretion?
1.190
1.191
1.192
1.193
1.194
1.195
Appropriate forum
1.196
1.197
1.198
1.199
Literature
1.200
Sufficient Connection with the Jurisdiction
Showing sufficient connection
1.201
1.202
1.203
1.204
COMI
1.205
Establishment
1.206
Only office and all shareholders in the jurisdiction
1.207
Branch office or agency in the jurisdiction
1.208
Business conducted in the jurisdiction
1.209
Having office, or place of business, or doing business in jurisdiction not necessary
1.210
1.211
1.212
Registration as an overseas company irrelevant
1.213
Assets in the jurisdiction and persons interested
1.214
1.215
1.216
1.217
1.218
1.219
1.220
Benefit to applicant or creditors and jurisdiction over person interested in distribution of assets
1.221
Miscellaneous factors
1.222
1.223
1.224
1.225
Sufficient Interest of Petitioner
1.226
1.227
1.228
1.229
Sufficient Connection of Petitioner with the Jurisdiction
1.230
1.231
1.232
Dissolved Foreign Corporations
Winding up despite dissolution
1.233
1.234
1.235
1.236
Status of a dissolved foreign corporation
1.237
1.238
1.239
Literature
1.240
Legislation Applied to Unregistered Companies
Unregistered Companies other than Insolvent Partnerships and European/UK Economic Interest Groupings
1.241
Insolvent Partnerships
Introduction
1.242
Article 7
1.243
1.244
Article 8
1.245
1.246
Article 9
1.247
1.248
Article 10
1.249
1.250
European/UK Economic Interest Groupings
1.251
Scope of other Company Insolvency Procedures
Bank and Building Society Insolvency
1.252
1.253
1.254
1.255
1.256
Part A1 Moratorium
1.257
1.258
Voluntary Arrangement
1.259
1.260
1.261
Schedule B1 Administration
1.262
1.263
Special Administration Regimes
Introduction
1.264
1.265
1.266
Water industry special administration
1.267
1.268
1.269
1.270
Protected railway companies: railway administration
1.271
1.272
1.273
Administration for building societies
1.274
PPP administration
1.275
1.276
Air traffic administration
1.277
1.278
Energy administration
1.279
1.280
Bank administration and building society special administration
1.281
1.282
1.283
1.284
1.285
Investment bank insolvency
1.286
Investment bank special administration
1.287
1.288
1.289
1.290
1.291
Special administration (bank insolvency)
1.292
1.293
Special administration (bank administration)
1.294
1.295
Postal administration
1.296
1.297
1.298
Energy supply company administration
1.299
1.300
1.301
Health special administration
1.302
1.303
1.304
FMI administration
1.305
1.306
1.307
1.308
Housing administration
1.309
1.310
Education administration
1.311
1.312
1.313
Administrative Receivership
1.314
1.315
Voluntary Winding Up
1.316
1.317
1.318
Entities which cannot be Wound Up under IA 1986
Introduction
Creation of exceptions
1.319
Jurisdiction allocated elsewhere
1.320
Effect of Regulation (EU) 2015/848
1.321
Company already being Wound Up by the Court
1.322
1.323
1.324
Special Administration Regimes
Water industry special administration
1.325
1.326
Railway administration
1.327
1.328
Building societies in administration
1.329
1.330
PPP administration
1.331
1.332
Air traffic administration
1.333
1.334
Special administration regimes based on schedule B1 administration
1.335
EEA Insurers
1.336
1.337
1.338
1.339
1.340
EEA Credit Institutions
1.341
1.342
1.343
1.344
1.345
EEA Investment Firms
1.346
1.347
EEA Group Companies in Resolution
1.348
1.349
Sovereign States
1.350
1.351
International Organizations
1.352
1.353
Illegal Associations
1.354
1.355
1.356
Inchoate Companies
1.357
1.358
Clubs
1.359
1.360
Non-business Societies
1.361
1.362
Societies with no Contractual Relationship between Members
1.363
1.364
Trade Unions
1.365
Unincorporated Trusts
1.366
Solvent Partnerships
1.367
1.368
Inherent Jurisdiction
Unincorporated associations
1.369
1.370
1.371
Corporations
1.372
Allocation of Jurisdiction within the EEA and Switzerland
Introduction
1.373
1.374
1.375
1.376
1.377
Geographical Extent
EU States
1.378
1.379
1.380
Aruba, French overseas departments, Iceland, Norway and Switzerland
1.381
1.382
1.383
EEA States
1.384
1.385
1.386
1.387
1.388
Jurisdiction over Winding Up on the Ground of Insolvency: Regulation (EU) 2015/848 before IP completion day
Scope
1.389
1.390
1.391
Jurisdiction over main, secondary and territorial insolvency proceedings
1.392
1.393
1.394
1.395
1.396
1.397
Recognition of judgments
1.398
1.399
Refusal of recognition for public policy reasons
1.400
1.401
Companies to which the Regulation does not apply: insurance, banking and investment
1.402
1.403
1.404
Companies to which the Regulation does not apply: COMI in Denmark or outside the EU
1.405
Literature
1.406
Jurisdiction over Winding Up on a Ground other than Insolvency: Regulation (EU) No 1215/2012, Brussels and Lugano Conventions
Seat of company determines jurisdiction
1.407
Location of seat
1.408
1.409
1.410
1.411
1.412
1.413
Where more than one State has jurisdiction
1.414
Forum non conveniens
1.415
Public interest petitions
1.416
Literature
1.417
Allocation of Jurisdiction between the UK and Gibraltar
1.418
Allocation of Jurisdiction within the UK
Civil Jurisdiction and Judgments Act 1982
1.419
Registered Companies
Companies registered in England and Wales or Scotland
1.420
1.421
1.422
1.423
Companies registered in Northern Ireland
1.424
1.425
Republic of Ireland companies
1.426
Entities treated as registered companies
1.427
1.428
1.429
1.430
Unregistered Companies, other than Insolvent Partnerships
1.431
1.432
1.433
1.434
Insolvent Partnerships
1.435
1.436
Companies Liable to be Wound Up under IA 1986
Jurisdiction to Sanction Companies’ Compromises and Arrangements
1.437
1.438
1.439
1.440
1.441
EEA Insurers, Credit Institutions, Investment Firms and Group Companies
1.442
1.443
1.444
Other EEA Companies
1.445
1.446
1.447
1.448
1.449
Court Jurisdiction
Registered Companies
General rule
1.450
1.451
1.452
1.453
Companies without share capital
1.454
County Court hearing centre
1.455
1.456
1.457
1.458
Building Societies
1.459
1.460
Incorporated Friendly Societies
1.461
Charitable Incorporated Organizations
1.462
Unregistered Companies other than Insolvent Partnerships
1.463
1.464
1.465
1.466
1.467
Insolvent Partnerships
Articles 7 and 8 (petitions other than by members)
1.468
1.469
1.470
Articles 9 and 10 (petitions by members)
1.471
1.472
Business must have been carried on in past three years
1.473
Principal place of business in Scotland or Northern Ireland
1.474
District registries cannot be used
1.475
Partnerships
1.476
Court of Appeal
1.477
International Jurisdiction
1.478
Meaning of ‘the Court’
1.479
Transfer of Proceedings between Courts
1.480
1.481
1.482
1.483
1.484
1.485
1.486
1.487
1.488
1.489
Effect of Proceeding in the Wrong Court
1.490
1.491
Judges and Court Officers
Distribution of Business between Judges and Court Officials
1.492
1.493
1.494
1.495
1.496
1.497
Official Receivers
Appointment and functions
1.498
1.499
1.500
1.501
1.502
1.503
1.504
1.505
1.506
1.507
Meaning of ‘the official receiver’
1.508
Qualified insolvency practitioners
1.509
1.510
1.511
1.512
Effect of Order Made Erroneously or without Jurisdiction
Error over Jurisdiction
1.513
1.514
1.515
1.516
Order Made without Jurisdiction
1.517
1.518
1.519
Time Limits, Notices and Service
Time Limits
Computation
1.520
1.521
Extension or shortening
1.522
1.523
Meaning of ‘business day’
1.524
Notices and Service
Form and content of notices
1.525
1.526
Gazetting
1.527
1.528
1.529
Rules on delivery and service of documents
1.530
Delivery methods
1.531
1.532
1.533
Authentication and proof of delivery
1.534
1.535
1.536
Delivery to authorized agent
1.537
Delivery to joint office-holders
1.538
Standard fee for copies
1.539
Registered Office
Service of documents at registered office
1.540
False representation
1.541
Unauthorized change
1.542
Building in multiple occupancy
1.543
Company no longer at its registered office
1.544
1.545
1.546
Principal office of a building society
1.547
Responsible Insolvency Practitioner; Office-holder; Member State Liquidator
1.548
1.549
1.550
1.551
Formal Defects
1.552
1.553
History
History of the Legislation
Before the introduction of incorporation by registration
1.554
1.555
1.556
1.557
Joint Stock Companies Act 1844
1.558
1.559
1.560
1.561
1.562
1.563
1.564
Joint Stock Companies Act 1856
1.565
1.566
1.567
1.568
1.569
Companies Act 1862
1.570
1.571
1.572
IA 1986
1.573
1.574
1.575
1.576
History of the Jurisdiction
Earliest registered companies
1.577
1.578
1.579
1.580
Joint Stock Companies Act 1856
1.581
Companies Act 1862 to the present
1.582
1.583
Partnerships: general partnerships
1.584
1.585
1.586
Partnerships: limited partnerships
1.587
Partnerships: small partnerships
1.588
Incorporated railway companies
1.589
1.590
1.591
1.592
1.593
Trustee savings banks
1.594
History of Court Jurisdiction
Registered and unregistered companies
1.595
1.596
1.597
Building societies and registered societies
1.598
Stannary courts
1.599
1.600
1.601
1.602
1.603
2 Presentation of a Winding-up Petition
Preliminary Material
Winding-up Petitions
Compulsory Winding Up must be Ordered under IA 1986
Court orders with winding-up effect
2.01
2.02
2.03
Arbitration
2.04
Originating Process for a Winding-up Order
2.05
2.06
2.07
Petitions
2.08
2.09
2.10
2.11
2.12
Juridical Classification of Winding-up Petitions
Action, claim, suit, proceeding
2.13
2.14
2.15
2.16
2.17
2.18
2.19
2.20
Against the company
2.21
Winding-up Order of Court’s Own Motion
2.22
2.23
2.24
Circumstances in which a Winding-up Order may be Made
Prescribed Circumstances must Exist
2.25
2.26
2.27
2.28
Registered Companies
Insolvency Act 1986, s 122(1)
2.29
Corporate members of insolvent partnerships
2.30
Entities Treated as Registered Companies
Building societies
2.31
2.32
Charitable incorporated organizations
2.33
European public limited-liability companies / UK societates
2.34
Further education bodies that are statutory corporations
2.35
Incorporated friendly societies
2.36
Limited liability partnerships
2.37
Registered societies
2.38
Unregistered Companies
2.39
2.40
2.41
Insolvent Partnerships
Articles 7 and 9
2.42
2.43
Article 8
2.44
2.45
Article 10
2.46
2.47
European/UK Economic Interest Groupings
2.48
2.49
Lloyd’s Reorganization
2.50
Bank and Building Society Insolvency
2.51
Persons with Standing to Petition
Need for Standing
Principle
2.52
2.53
2.54
2.55
2.56
2.57
2.58
2.59
2.60
Corporate petitioners
2.61
Petition by solicitor on behalf of client
2.62
2.63
Death of petitioner
2.64
Executor
2.65
Petitioner without standing
2.66
2.67
Standing in relation to any Registered or Unregistered Company
2.68
2.69
2.70
2.71
2.72
Additional Standing in relation to Particular Types of Company
Introduction
2.73
Specific types of company: public bodies and officers
2.74
European/UK economic interest groupings
2.75
Lloyd’s and its members
2.76
Open-ended investment companies
2.77
Protected cell companies
2.78
Building Societies
2.79
Incorporated Friendly Societies
2.80
Insolvent Partnerships
Article 7
2.81
2.82
Article 8
2.83
Article 9
2.84
Article 10
2.85
Collective Investment Schemes
2.86
Company Subject to Existing Insolvency Procedure
2.87
Territorial Proceedings
2.88
2.89
Disputes about Standing to Petition for Winding Up
2.90
2.91
2.92
Bank and Building Society Insolvency
2.93
2.94
2.95
2.96
2.97
2.98
Permission, Consent or Prior Notice Required
Part A1 Moratorium
2.99
Administration
Interim moratorium
2.100
2.101
During administration
2.102
2.103
Receiver
2.104
Air Traffic Services Licence Companies
2.105
Stabilization of Financial Institutions
2.106
2.107
Residual Banks and Building Societies
2.108
Lloyd’s Reorganization
2.109
2.110
Reserve and Auxiliary Forces
2.111
Enemy Companies
2.112
Purpose, Motive and Interest
Purpose of Petitioner; Abuse of Process
Benefit for all creditors and contributories
2.113
2.114
2.115
2.116
2.117
2.118
Coercion to settle another dispute
2.119
2.120
2.121
2.122
Improper collateral purpose
2.123
Purposes that are not improper
2.124
2.125
2.126
Motive of Petitioner
2.127
2.128
2.129
Sufficient Interest of Petitioner; Companies without Assets
Petitioner must have sufficient interest
2.130
2.131
What constitutes a sufficient interest?
2.132
2.133
2.134
Onus
2.135
Petition costs not a sufficient interest
2.136
2.137
Companies without free assets
2.138
Absence of free assets and absence of any other interest
2.139
2.140
Recovery of further assets by liquidator
2.141
Representation of unsecured creditors’ interests
2.142
Unsecured creditors’ interest: feeding a floating charge
2.143
Injunction against Presenting a Petition
Injunction to Prevent Abuse of Process
Principle
2.144
2.145
Conditions for granting a quia timet injunction
2.146
2.147
2.148
2.149
2.150
Abuse of process
2.151
Alternative basis: petition must fail
2.152
2.153
2.154
2.155
2.156
Procedure
2.157
2.158
2.159
2.160
2.161
2.162
2.163
Condition for granting a temporary injunction
2.164
Stay of injunction
2.165
The Court’s Approach
2.166
2.167
2.168
2.169
Examples
Disputed debt petitions
2.170
2.171
Oppression
2.172
2.173
Collateral purpose
2.174
2.175
Suitable alternative remedy
2.176
2.177
2.178
Bound to fail as a matter of law or because of lack of evidence
2.179
Further cases
2.180
Costs
2.181
Tortious Petitions
Malicious Presentation or Continuation
Definition of tort
2.182
2.183
Proceedings ended in the company’s favour
2.184
Reasonable or probable cause
2.185
2.186
Malice
2.187
Malicious continuation of proceedings
2.188
Collateral Abuse of Process
2.189
Procedure
2.190
Form and Contents of Petition
Prescribed Forms of Petition
2.191
2.192
2.193
2.194
2.195
2.196
2.197
2.198
2.199
Contents of Petition
Prescribed contents
2.200
2.201
2.202
2.203
2.204
Witness statement
2.205
2.206
Reasons before IP completion day
2.207
How to determine whether proceedings are main, secondary, territorial or non-EU proceedings
2.208
2.209
2.210
Reasons from IP completion day
2.211
How to determine whether proceedings are COMI proceedings, establishment proceedings or proceedings to which the EU Regulation as it has effect in the law of the United Kingdom does not apply
2.212
Participant in a payment or securities settlement system
2.213
2.214
2.215
Grounds
2.216
2.217
2.218
2.219
2.220
2.221
2.222
2.223
Application
2.224
Company struck off the register
2.225
Verification of Petition
Requirement for verification
2.226
2.227
2.228
2.229
More than one petition
2.230
Insolvent partnerships
2.231
Bank or building society insolvency application
2.232
Sanction
2.233
Further Witness Statement
2.234
Filing, Venue and Track Allocation
General Rules on Filing and Fixing of Venue
Filing a petition
2.235
2.236
2.237
Fixing a venue
2.238
Number of copies to be filed: winding-up petition
2.239
2.240
2.241
2.242
Number of copies to be filed: application for a bank or building society insolvency order
2.243
Special Rules for Petitions to Wind Up Insolvent Partnerships
2.244
2.245
2.246
Track Allocation
2.247
Fee and Deposit
2.248
2.249
2.250
2.251
2.252
2.253
2.254
No Undertaking as to Damages
2.255
Court Files
Court Files
2.256
2.257
2.258
2.259
Inspection and Copying
Winding up
2.260
2.261
2.262
2.263
Bank or building society insolvency
2.264
2.265
2.266
2.267
Application for Permission to Inspect or Copy a Court File
Winding-up proceedings
2.268
Bank and building society insolvency proceedings
2.269
Office Copies of Documents on the Court File
2.270
3 Between Presentation and Hearing
Preliminary Material
Service of Petition
Service on the Company Sought to be Wound Up
General rule
3.01
3.02
3.03
3.04
3.05
3.06
3.07
3.08
Service on solicitor
3.09
Service of petition to wind up a registered company
3.10
3.11
3.12
3.13
3.14
3.15
Where service at registered office will not bring the petition to the company’s attention
3.16
3.17
Service of petition to wind up unregistered company
3.18
3.19
3.20
3.21
3.22
Overseas companies
3.23
Alternative service
3.24
3.25
3.26
Service outside the jurisdiction
3.27
3.28
Verification of service
3.29
3.30
3.31
3.32
3.33
Service at the wrong place
3.34
Application for a bank or building society insolvency order
3.35
3.36
3.37
3.38
Copies of Winding-up Petition for other Persons
3.39
3.40
3.41
Notice of Petition
Companies for which special administration orders may be made
3.42
Financial institutions, holding companies and subsidiaries
3.43
3.44
3.45
3.46
3.47
3.48
Registered social landlords
3.49
Copies of Bank or Building Society Insolvency Application for other Persons
3.50
3.51
Restraint of Gazetting and Striking Out
Principle
3.52
3.53
3.54
3.55
3.56
3.57
3.58
Procedure
Inherent jurisdiction
3.59
3.60
Application
3.61
3.62
Temporary order
3.63
3.64
The Court’s Approach
3.65
3.66
Examples
Disputed debt petitions
3.67
3.68
Oppression
3.69
Collateral purpose
3.70
Suitable alternative remedy
3.71
3.72
Bound to fail as a matter of law or because of lack of evidence
3.73
3.74
3.75
3.76
Petition prohibited by or under statute
3.77
Petitioner contractually bound not to petition
3.78
Effect of Delay
3.79
Costs
3.80
Adjournment pending Appeal
3.81
Stay of Petition against Financial Institution
3.82
Summary Judgment
3.83
Starting other Insolvency Procedures after Presentation of a Winding-up Petition
Part A1 Moratorium
3.84
3.85
3.86
3.87
Moratorium for Preparation of a Partnership Voluntary Arrangement
3.88
Preparation for Administration
Interim moratorium before administration
3.89
3.90
Presentation of a petition or application for a special administration order
3.91
3.92
3.93
3.94
Going into Administration
Appointment of administrator by court
3.95
3.96
3.97
3.98
Appointment of administrator by holder of floating charge
3.99
3.100
3.101
Appointment of administrator by company or directors
3.102
3.103
3.104
3.105
Bank and Building Society Insolvency
3.106
Information about a Winding-up Petition in Applications for other Insolvency Procedures
Schedule B1 administration
3.107
Special administration regimes
3.108
3.109
3.110
What must be served on the winding-up petitioner
3.111
Appearance by the winding-up petitioner
3.112
Subsequent awareness of a winding-up petition
3.113
Publicity for Petition
Gazetting
Requirement
3.114
3.115
3.116
3.117
Timing
3.118
Filing
3.119
Notice not in accordance with the rules
3.120
3.121
3.122
Failure to give notice
3.123
Court’s direction not to give notice
3.124
3.125
3.126
Insolvent partnerships
3.127
Provision of Copies of the Petition
3.128
Other Publicity for the Petition
3.129
3.130
3.131
3.132
3.133
Errors in Notices
Effects of an error
3.134
3.135
Misdescription of the company sought to be wound up
3.136
3.137
3.138
3.139
3.140
3.141
3.142
Other errors
3.143
3.144
3.145
Dispensing with Gazetting
3.146
3.147
Bank or Building Society Insolvency Application
3.148
Certificate of Compliance
3.149
3.150
3.151
3.152
3.153
3.154
3.155
Permission to Withdraw a Petition
Withdrawal under IR 2016
3.156
3.157
3.158
3.159
3.160
3.161
3.162
3.163
Simultaneous Petitions in respect of an Insolvent Partnership and its Members
3.164
3.165
3.166
Inherent Jurisdiction
3.167
3.168
3.169
Notice of Appearance
3.170
Company’s Evidence in Opposition
3.171
3.172
3.173
Substitution of Petitioner
Introduction
3.174
3.175
3.176
3.177
3.178
3.179
Circumstances in which a Substitution may be Made
3.180
3.181
3.182
3.183
3.184
Who may be Substituted
3.185
3.186
3.187
3.188
Procedure
3.189
3.190
3.191
3.192
Effect of Substitution
3.193
Discretion of the Court
3.194
3.195
3.196
3.197
3.198
Amendment of Petition
Applicable Rules
3.199
3.200
Introduction of a New Ground
3.201
3.202
3.203
3.204
Correction of the Company’s Name
3.205
Correction of the Petitioner’s Name
3.206
Further Information and Disclosure
3.207
3.208
3.209
3.210
Security for Costs
Applicable Rules
3.211
Examples
Petitioner resident outside the jurisdiction
3.212
3.213
3.214
Impecunious company
3.215
Petitioner failing to give an address
3.216
Nominal claimant
3.217
Effect of Delay in Applying
3.218
Petition against Member of Insolvent Partnership
3.219
Inordinate Delay and Negligence
Inordinate Delay
3.220
3.221
3.222
3.223
Negligent Conduct of Petition
3.224
Applications in Insolvency Proceedings
Procedural Rules
3.225
Originating Process and Fee
3.226
3.227
3.228
3.229
3.230
3.231
Contents of an Application
3.232
3.233
3.234
Filing
3.235
Venue, Directions, Track Allocation
3.236
3.237
3.238
3.239
3.240
Service
3.241
3.242
3.243
Evidence
3.244
3.245
3.246
3.247
3.248
3.249
3.250
Adjournment
3.251
Striking Out
3.252
Applications in Bank and Building Society Insolvency Proceedings
3.253
3.254
3.255
Protecting a Company’s Property while a Winding-up Petition is Pending
3.256
3.257
3.258
3.259
3.260
3.261
3.262
4 Appointment of a Provisional Liquidator
Preliminary Material
Purpose of Appointment
Function of a Provisional Liquidator
Power to appoint
4.01
4.02
4.03
4.04
4.05
4.06
4.07
Object of appointment
4.08
4.09
4.10
4.11
Alternative appointment of receiver
4.12
4.13
4.14
Liquidation, insolvency and winding up
4.15
4.16
4.17
Effect on Company Governance and Contracts
4.18
4.19
4.20
4.21
Effect on Litigation
4.22
Effect on Part A1 Moratorium
4.23
Effect on Administration
4.24
No Deemed Insolvency; Opening of Insolvency Proceedings
4.25
Is a Provisional Liquidator a Liquidator?
4.26
4.27
Provisional Liquidator as Insolvency Practitioner in EU Regulation
4.28
Applying for Appointment
Who may Apply
4.29
4.30
4.31
4.32
Application Procedure
Form of application
4.33
4.34
4.35
Notice
4.36
4.37
Hearing
4.38
The court’s order
4.39
4.40
4.41
4.42
Cross-undertaking in damages
4.43
4.44
Application in the public interest
4.45
Application without Notice to the Company
When can a provisional liquidator be appointed without notice?
4.46
4.47
4.48
4.49
Applicant’s duty of disclosure
4.50
4.51
Application to set aside appointment
4.52
Restrictions on Appointing Provisional Liquidators to Certain Types of Companies
Air traffic services licence companies
4.53
Protected energy companies, energy supply companies, universal service provider
4.54
EEA insurers, credit institutions, investment firms and group companies
4.55
Changes in Practice
4.56
4.57
4.58
4.59
Who will be Appointed
Independence
4.60
4.61
4.62
4.63
4.64
4.65
Qualification
4.66
4.67
4.68
4.69
4.70
4.71
Groups of Companies
4.72
Insolvent Partnerships
4.73
When an Appointment will be Made
Winding-up Order is Likely to be Made
4.74
4.75
4.76
4.77
4.78
4.79
4.80
Application Supported by the Company
Appointment not automatic
4.81
Application by directors
4.82
Where there are no directors
4.83
Appointment to manage company’s run-down
4.84
4.85
Appointment so as to stay litigation
4.86
Application not Supported by the Company
The court’s attitude
4.87
4.88
4.89
4.90
4.91
4.92
4.93
Protection of assets
4.94
4.95
4.96
4.97
4.98
Protection of persons dealing with the company
4.99
Investigation
4.100
4.101
Deadlock
4.102
Administrative vacuum
4.103
To provide alternative management
4.104
Danger of prejudice to contributory petitioner
4.105
Public interest
4.106
Removal of voluntary liquidator
4.107
Applicant’s private advantage not enough
4.108
4.109
Order of Appointment
Form of Order
4.110
4.111
4.112
4.113
Transmission
4.114
4.115
4.116
Public Notification
4.117
4.118
4.119
4.120
Joint Provisional Liquidators
4.121
Defective Appointment
4.122
4.123
4.124
Remuneration and Expenses
Official Receiver: Rate of Remuneration
4.125
Official Receiver: Deposit and Payment of Remuneration
4.126
4.127
Provisional Liquidator Other than the Official Receiver: Fixing Remuneration
4.128
4.129
4.130
4.131
Payment of Remuneration and Expenses
Appointment ended before substantive hearing of petition
4.132
No winding-up order made
4.133
4.134
Winding-up order made
4.135
4.136
4.137
Functions and Powers of a Provisional Liquidator
4.138
4.139
4.140
4.141
4.142
4.143
4.144
4.145
4.146
4.147
4.148
4.149
Effect of Administrative Receivership
4.150
4.151
4.152
Vacation of Office
4.153
4.154
4.155
4.156
4.157
4.158
4.159
4.160
4.161
4.162
4.163
5 Hearing the Petition and Making the Order
Preliminary Material
Judge
Judicial Nature of Decision
5.01
5.02
Judge
5.03
Management with Related Proceedings
5.04
5.05
5.06
Who may be Heard
Right to be Heard
Petitioner
5.07
The company: professional representation
5.08
The company: non-professional representation
5.09
5.10
Persons capable of being parties
5.11
5.12
5.13
5.14
5.15
5.16
Examples of persons the court has refused to hear
5.17
5.18
Secured creditors
5.19
The company’s insolvency office-holder
5.20
5.21
5.22
5.23
5.24
Contributories
5.25
5.26
Contributories’ petitions
5.27
5.28
Financial Conduct Authority and Prudential Regulation Authority
5.29
5.30
Insolvent partnerships
5.31
Bank or building society insolvency application
5.32
5.33
Notice of Appearance or Permission to be Heard
Notice of appearance
5.34
5.35
5.36
5.37
List of persons intending to appear
5.38
Permission of the court to appear without notice to the petitioner
5.39
5.40
5.41
Security for Costs
5.42
Evidence
Written and Oral Evidence
Written evidence preferred
5.43
Verified petition
5.44
Other evidence
5.45
Contributories’ petitions
5.46
Cross-examination
5.47
5.48
5.49
5.50
5.51
5.52
Available Arguments
Only allegations in petitions may be heard
5.53
5.54
5.55
5.56
Defence rejected in previous application
5.57
Views of Creditors and/or Contributories other than the Petitioner
5.58
5.59
5.60
5.61
5.62
5.63
Inspectors’ Reports and other Investigative Materials
5.64
Report on Petitions against Members of Insolvent Partnership
5.65
Orders the Court may Make
Orders Available to the Court
General
5.66
5.67
5.68
5.69
Companies which may not be wound up
5.70
Exercising special administration powers
5.71
Alternative orders for financial institutions
5.72
Winding-up Order
Principle
5.73
5.74
When an order takes effect
5.75
5.76
5.77
Discretion whether to Make an Order or Not
Discretion of court
5.78
5.79
5.80
5.81
Discretion must be exercised judicially
5.82
5.83
5.84
5.85
5.86
5.87
5.88
No assets
5.89
Duration, cost and complexity of winding up
5.90
5.91
Small number of members
5.92
Mandatory winding-up orders
5.93
Requirement that notice must have been given
5.94
Companies incorporated for public purposes
5.95
5.96
5.97
5.98
5.99
Juridical Classification of a Winding-up Order
Finality
5.100
5.101
5.102
In rem or in personam
5.103
Dismissal of Petition
5.104
5.105
5.106
Adjournment
Principle
5.107
5.108
5.109
5.110
5.111
5.112
Policy against long or repeated adjournments
5.113
5.114
5.115
5.116
Related criminal proceedings
5.117
5.118
Application by petitioner opposed by other creditors
5.119
Application by company or contributory
5.120
5.121
Application by other creditors on creditor’s petition
5.122
5.123
5.124
Building societies
5.125
Incorporated friendly societies
5.126
Interim or other Order; Alternative Remedies
Scope of an interim or other order
5.127
5.128
5.129
5.130
5.131
5.132
5.133
5.134
Provisions in winding-up order for conduct of the winding up
5.135
5.136
5.137
Alternative remedy for insurers
5.138
5.139
Interim costs
5.140
Appointment of a Liquidator
The official receiver
5.141
5.142
Administrator or supervisor of voluntary arrangement
5.143
5.144
5.145
5.146
5.147
5.148
5.149
5.150
Insurers
5.151
Building societies and incorporated friendly societies
5.152
Bank and building society insolvency orders
5.153
History
5.154
Company Already Subject to an Insolvency Procedure
5.155
Application to Commence another Insolvency Procedure
Administration Applications
Reference to winding-up petition in administration application and service on winding-up petitioner
5.156
On making an administration order
5.157
Treating an administration application as a winding-up petition
5.158
5.159
5.160
Making a bank or building society insolvency order on an administration application or petition
5.161
Petitions and Applications for Special Administration Orders
Petition or application pending for special administration order
5.162
5.163
Contents of administration application and service on winding-up petitioner
5.164
Treating a winding-up petition as an application for a special administration order
5.165
Treating a special administration application as a winding-up petition
5.166
Dismissal of winding-up petition on making a special administration order
5.167
5.168
Concurrent Petitions against an Insolvent Partnership and One or More Members
5.169
5.170
5.171
5.172
5.173
5.174
5.175
5.176
5.177
Costs
5.178
General
5.179
5.180
Petitioner
Winding-up order made
5.181
5.182
5.183
5.184
5.185
5.186
No winding-up order made and petition debt not paid
5.187
5.188
5.189
5.190
5.191
5.192
No winding-up order made but petition debt paid
5.193
5.194
5.195
Petition adjourned but company goes into voluntary liquidation
5.196
Travelling and subsistence
5.197
The Company
Winding-up order made
5.198
5.199
5.200
5.201
No winding-up order made
5.202
Voluntary liquidator
5.203
Company petitioning for its own winding up
5.204
Supporting Creditors and Contributories
Winding-up order made
5.205
5.206
5.207
No winding-up order made
5.208
Opposing Creditors and Contributories
Winding-up order made
5.209
No winding-up order made
5.210
5.211
5.212
Opposer subject to a freezing injunction
5.213
Where there is both a Winding-up Petition and an Administration Application
5.214
5.215
5.216
Order of Payment out of the Company’s Assets
Set-off
5.217
Expenses of the winding up
5.218
5.219
5.220
Witnesses
5.221
Assessment
5.222
5.223
5.224
5.225
5.226
Parallel Petitions
Only One Petition Necessary
5.227
5.228
5.229
5.230
Consolidation
5.231
5.232
Historical
5.233
5.234
5.235
5.236
Petitions in Different Courts
Priority of petition heard first
5.237
Transfer
5.238
5.239
5.240
5.241
Costs
5.242
Costs when order is made on earlier petition
5.243
Costs when order is made on later petition
5.244
5.245
Notice to Official Receiver and Perfection of Order
5.246
5.247
Public Notification of a Winding-up Order
The Official Receiver, the Company, Companies House
5.248
5.249
5.250
Official Notification
5.251
5.252
5.253
5.254
Gazetting and Advertisement
5.255
5.256
5.257
Notification in EU States
5.258
5.259
5.260
Company’s Documents and Websites
5.261
5.262
Building Societies, Incorporated Friendly Societies and Registered Societies
5.263
5.264
European/UK Economic Interest Groupings
5.265
Registered Social Landlords
5.266
Insurers, Credit Institutions and Investment Firms
5.267
5.268
5.269
5.270
5.271
5.272
Participant in a Payment or Securities Settlement System
5.273
Public Notification of Dismissal of a Petition
5.274
5.275
Commencement of Winding Up, Going into Liquidation etc
Commencement
Introduction
5.276
5.277
Company not in voluntary winding up when petition presented and order not made on an administration application
5.278
5.279
5.280
Commencement of voluntary winding up
5.281
5.282
5.283
5.284
5.285
5.286
5.287
Company in voluntary winding up when petition presented
5.288
5.289
5.290
5.291
Winding-up order made on administration application
5.292
Coronavirus pandemic temporary provision
5.293
While winding-up petition is pending
5.294
5.295
5.296
5.297
5.298
Building societies
5.299
Incorporated friendly societies
5.300
Unregistered companies
5.301
Open-ended investment companies
5.302
Winding up under the supervision of the court
5.303
Going into Liquidation
5.304
5.305
5.306
Summary
5.307
Commencement of Bank or Building Society Insolvency
5.308
5.309
Becoming Insolvent
5.310
5.311
5.312
5.313
Is Wound Up
5.314
6 Review of Orders
Preliminary Material
Correction of Slips
6.01
6.02
6.03
6.04
Recall or Setting Aside of an Order Made on a Winding-up Petition
Recall
6.05
Setting Aside
Fundamentally defective order
6.06
6.07
Company’s failure to attend hearing
6.08
6.09
6.10
Other reasons for setting aside
6.11
Review, Rescission or Variation
Power to Review, Rescind or Vary an Order
Principle
6.12
6.13
6.14
6.15
Who may exercise the power
6.16
6.17
6.18
Nature of process
6.19
6.20
The court’s approach
6.21
Application must be prompt
6.22
Fresh evidence
6.23
6.24
Rescission of a Winding-up Order
Purpose of application
6.25
6.26
Who may apply
6.27
Time limit
6.28
6.29
6.30
6.31
Notice of application
6.32
Attendance
6.33
The court’s approach
6.34
6.35
Official receiver’s expenses
6.36
Company did not attend hearing at which order was made
6.37
6.38
6.39
Order made against the wrong company
6.40
Petitioner unaware of company’s voluntary liquidation
6.41
Appeal
Tribunal and Permission to Appeal
Permission to appeal
6.42
From County Court decision
6.43
6.44
From High Court first-instance decision other than by a High Court judge
6.45
6.46
6.47
6.48
From first-instance decision by a High Court judge
6.49
6.50
6.51
Procedure
Rules
6.52
Time limit
6.53
Standing to Appeal
6.54
6.55
6.56
6.57
6.58
6.59
6.60
Security for Costs
6.61
Stay of Proceedings in a Winding Up pending Appeal
6.62
6.63
Nature of Appeal Process
6.64
6.65
6.66
6.67
6.68
6.69
6.70
6.71
6.72
6.73
6.74
Role of Liquidator
6.75
Setting Aside Winding-up Order not Practicable
6.76
Setting Aside Winding-up Order Nullifying Proceedings Commenced by Liquidator
6.77
Costs
6.78
6.79
6.80
Stay
Enactments under which Stay may be Ordered
Winding up by the court, bank and building society insolvency
6.81
6.82
6.83
Voluntary winding up
6.84
Insolvent partnerships
6.85
Group coordination proceedings
6.86
Effect of Stay
General effect
6.87
Effect on the winding-up order
6.88
Effect on previous proceedings in the winding up
6.89
6.90
Stay for a limited period
6.91
Application for a Stay
Who may apply
6.92
6.93
Notice of application
6.94
Evidence
6.95
6.96
6.97
Insolvent partnerships
6.98
The Court’s Approach
Onus
6.99
Interests to be considered
6.100
Creditors
6.101
6.102
6.103
6.104
6.105
The liquidator
6.106
6.107
Members
6.108
Public interest
6.109
6.110
Where there will be a surplus
6.111
6.112
Outstanding disputes
6.113
6.114
Australian list of eight principles
6.115
Stay in Favour of other Winding-up Proceedings
6.116
6.117
6.118
6.119
6.120
Stay in Favour of Administration
6.121
6.122
6.123
Stay when Voluntary Arrangement has been Approved
Registered companies
6.124
6.125
6.126
Limited liability partnerships
6.127
Building societies
6.128
Insolvent partnerships
6.129
Bank and building society insolvency
6.130
Company in Voluntary Liquidation Resuming Business
6.131
6.132
Wrongly Made Winding-up Order
6.133
Making an Order to Stay
Incidental directions
6.134
6.135
Further conditions: building societies
6.136
6.137
Further conditions: incorporated friendly societies
6.138
6.139
Further order: insolvent partnerships
6.140
Notification of stay
6.141
Effect of Staying a Stay
6.142
Discharge on Making an Administration Order
6.143
6.144
6.145
6.146
6.147
6.148
6.149
Conversion of Secondary Winding Up
6.150
6.151
Conversion of Investment Bank Winding Up
6.152
6.153
History
6.154
6.155
6.156
6.157
6.158
6.159
7 Petitions by Creditors
Preliminary Material
Standing of Creditors to Petition and Circumstances in which they may Petition
Creditor or Creditors
7.01
7.02
7.03
7.04
Grounds
7.05
7.06
7.07
Reasonable Pre-action Conduct
Reasonable pre-action conduct required
7.08
Informing the company of the claimed debt
7.09
7.10
7.11
7.12
Cases outside the CPR
7.13
7.14
7.15
7.16
Should a creditor be required to obtain judgment and attempt execution?
7.17
7.18
Limitation
7.19
Nature of Creditors’ Petitions to Wind Up Insolvent Companies
Function of Creditors’ Petitions which Allege Inability to Pay Debts
Individual and collective remedy
7.20
7.21
7.22
7.23
7.24
7.25
Focus on individual remedy
7.26
7.27
7.28
7.29
7.30
7.31
7.32
Focus on collective remedy
7.33
7.34
7.35
Unpaid creditor of a solvent company
7.36
7.37
7.38
Unnecessary to try other means of enforcement
7.39
7.40
7.41
7.42
Creditor petitioning for winding up and taking other proceedings to recover the debt
7.43
7.44
7.45
7.46
7.47
7.48
Undisputed creditor may petition to force settlement
7.49
Juridical Classification of Creditors’ Petitions Alleging Inability to Pay Debts
Juridical classification of winding-up petitions
7.50
Not a claim for payment of a debt
7.51
7.52
Not execution or enforcement
7.53
7.54
7.55
7.56
Not an action on a judgment
7.57
Founded on, but not enforcement of, a contract under which the petition debt was incurred
7.58
7.59
Means of obtaining payment
7.60
Remedy
7.61
Recovery
7.62
7.63
Giving effect to judgment or order
7.64
In respect of the creditor’s debt
7.65
Proof of Inability to Pay Debts
Meaning of ‘Unable to Pay its Debts’
Legislative definition of inability to pay debts
7.66
Which debts must be considered?
7.67
7.68
7.69
7.70
7.71
7.72
7.73
Rates, council tax, BID levy and community infrastructure levy
7.74
7.75
Future and contingent debts
7.76
7.77
Tests
7.78
7.79
7.80
7.81
7.82
7.83
Burden of Proof
7.84
7.85
Methods of Proving a Company is Unable to Pay its Debts
Registered companies
7.86
7.87
Effect of coronavirus
7.88
7.89
7.90
7.91
Section 123 creates six separate methods of proof
7.92
7.93
7.94
7.95
Discretion whether to order winding up remains
7.96
Location of full commentary on statutory methods of proof
7.97
Is section 123 an exclusive definition of inability to pay debts?
7.98
7.99
7.100
7.101
7.102
7.103
Unregistered companies
7.104
7.105
7.106
7.107
7.108
Insolvent partnership: no concurrent petition against a member
7.109
7.110
7.111
7.112
Insolvent partnership: concurrent petitions against one or more members
7.113
7.114
7.115
7.116
7.117
Building societies
7.118
Incorporated friendly societies
7.119
Main insolvency proceedings in a foreign EU State
7.120
Foreign main proceeding
7.121
Statutory Demand
Nature of Statutory Demand
Definition
7.122
7.123
7.124
Bankruptcy statutory demands
7.125
Juridical classification
7.126
7.127
7.128
7.129
Strict adherence
7.130
7.131
Building societies
7.132
Incorporated friendly societies
7.133
Form of Demand
Prescribed contents
7.134
7.135
7.136
CIOs and relevant schemes
7.137
Demand by an agent
7.138
Insolvent partnerships
7.139
7.140
Method and Place of Service of Demand
Permitted methods of service
7.141
7.142
7.143
What constitutes leaving; use of a postal operator
7.144
7.145
7.146
7.147
7.148
7.149
Service out of office hours
7.150
Service at building in multiple occupancy
7.151
Service according to rules does not bring demand to company’s attention
7.152
7.153
7.154
7.155
7.156
7.157
7.158
Unregistered companies
7.159
Type of Debt for which Demand may be Served
Debt must be due and payable
7.160
7.161
7.162
7.163
7.164
Debt in which more than one creditor is interested
7.165
7.166
7.167
7.168
7.169
7.170
Joint debtors
7.171
Judgment debt
7.172
7.173
7.174
7.175
Secured creditors
7.176
Debt in a foreign currency
7.177
Amount accruing
7.178
Method of Compliance
Time for payment
7.179
7.180
7.181
7.182
7.183
Place of payment
7.184
Payment must be unconditional
7.185
Security for sum due
7.186
7.187
7.188
7.189
7.190
7.191
Composition and compromise
7.192
7.193
7.194
7.195
Reasonable Excuse for not Complying
7.196
7.197
Error in and Dispute about the Contents of a Statutory Demand
Effect of errors
7.198
7.199
7.200
Effect of errors: Australia
7.201
7.202
7.203
7.204
7.205
Misnomer of the company
7.206
7.207
7.208
Demand served by wrong person
7.209
Disputed debt
7.210
7.211
7.212
7.213
Mistaken statement of amount; partially disputed amount
7.214
7.215
7.216
7.217
7.218
Validity of a statutory demand which overstates the amount indisputably due
7.219
7.220
7.221
7.222
7.223
7.224
Literature
7.225
Mistake in time allowed for compliance
7.226
Withdrawal of a Statutory Demand
7.227
Abuse of the Statutory Demand Procedure
7.228
7.229
7.230
Setting Aside Statutory Demands
7.231
Ban during Coronavirus Pandemic
7.232
Unsatisfied Execution
7.233
7.234
7.235
7.236
7.237
7.238
Cash Flow Test
Current Statutory Provisions
7.239
7.240
7.241
7.242
7.243
History
7.244
7.245
7.246
7.247
7.248
Application of the Cash Flow Test
7.249
7.250
7.251
7.252
7.253
7.254
Admission
7.255
7.256
Non-payment of One Debt
7.257
7.258
7.259
7.260
7.261
7.262
7.263
7.264
7.265
7.266
Appointment of a Receiver
7.267
7.268
Balance Sheet Test
Current Statutory Provisions
7.269
7.270
Application of the Balance Sheet Test
7.271
7.272
7.273
7.274
7.275
7.276
7.277
7.278
Is Deemed Inability to Pay Debts Rebuttable?
Evidentiary Purpose of Deeming
7.279
7.280
7.281
7.282
When does the Deemed Inability to Pay Debts Take Effect?
No time frame in legislation
7.283
First theory: deeming begins with court’s decision
7.284
Second theory: deeming begins with deeming event and may come to an end before the hearing
7.285
7.286
Evidence in Rebuttal of Deemed Inability to Pay Debts
7.287
7.288
7.289
7.290
7.291
Legislative Solutions in Australia and New Zealand
7.292
7.293
Which Creditors may Petition
Meaning of ‘Creditor’
7.294
7.295
7.296
7.297
7.298
7.299
7.300
7.301
7.302
Contingent and Prospective Creditors
Standing of contingent and prospective creditors
7.303
7.304
7.305
7.306
Grounds
7.307
7.308
Definition of contingent creditor and prospective creditor
7.309
7.310
7.311
7.312
7.313
7.314
7.315
7.316
7.317
7.318
Existing obligation
7.319
7.320
7.321
7.322
7.323
7.324
Incurring an obligation
7.325
7.326
7.327
7.328
7.329
7.330
7.331
7.332
Debt to be quantified
7.333
7.334
7.335
7.336
7.337
7.338
7.339
7.340
Contingent non-monetary obligation
7.341
7.342
7.343
Dispute about the Existence of the Debt
Effect of a dispute
7.344
No standing to petition if existence of debt disputed
7.345
Alternative views
7.346
Winding-up court’s unwillingness to determine questions of standing
7.347
7.348
7.349
7.350
7.351
Disputed claimant as creditor
7.352
7.353
7.354
7.355
7.356
Under the Joint Stock Companies Act 1856
7.357
Disputed claimant as contingent or prospective creditor
7.358
7.359
7.360
7.361
Jointly Owned Debts
7.362
Assigned Debts
7.363
7.364
7.365
7.366
7.367
7.368
Attached Debts
Attached debt owed by a company
7.369
7.370
Attached debt owed by a company’s creditor
7.371
Uncertainty of Amount of Claim or Time for Payment
7.372
7.373
7.374
7.375
Small Debts
7.376
7.377
7.378
7.379
7.380
7.381
Secured Creditors and Holders of Debt Securities
7.382
7.383
7.384
7.385
Payment by Cheque
7.386
Judgment Debts and Arbitration Awards
Judgment or award in England and Wales
7.387
7.388
7.389
7.390
7.391
Judgment after petition presented
7.392
Foreign Judgments (Reciprocal Enforcement) Act 1933
7.393
7.394
7.395
Registration of other foreign judgments
7.396
7.397
Execution Creditors
7.398
Taxes
7.399
7.400
7.401
7.402
7.403
Unenforceable Claims
7.404
7.405
Unprovable Claims
7.406
7.407
7.408
7.409
7.410
7.411
Alternative Formulations of Claim
7.412
Debt in Receivership
7.413
Creditor Bound not to Petition
7.414
7.415
7.416
Creditor Pursuing other Claims against Company
7.417
Beneficial Interest in Trust Property
7.418
Insolvent Partnerships
7.419
7.420
Disputed Debt and Cross-claim Petitions
Introduction
Disputed debt petitions
7.421
7.422
7.423
7.424
7.425
7.426
7.427
Cross-claim petitions
7.428
Arbitration agreement
7.429
Taxes
7.430
Literature
7.431
Determination of Disputes about Petition Debts
Generally disputes about petition debts will not be resolved in proceedings on the petition
7.432
7.433
Unsuitability of petition procedure
7.434
7.435
Detriment to the company
7.436
7.437
7.438
7.439
Exceptional cases
7.440
7.441
7.442
7.443
7.444
Treatment of Disputed Debt Petition at Substantive Hearing
Principle
7.445
Disputed existence of debt
7.446
7.447
7.448
7.449
7.450
7.451
7.452
7.453
Disputed amount or timing
7.454
7.455
7.456
Partially disputed debt
7.457
7.458
Adjournment of a Disputed Debt Petition
Circumstances in which a disputed debt petition may be adjourned
7.459
7.460
Where company would be unable to pay the petition debt
7.461
7.462
7.463
7.464
Where company active
7.465
Where company solvent
7.466
7.467
Making a Winding-up Order on a Disputed Debt Petition
Principle
7.468
7.469
7.470
7.471
7.472
Where a winding-up order is made on a concurrent petition
7.473
Revival of dissolved unregistered company
7.474
Where the petitioner would be without a remedy
7.475
7.476
7.477
Where the company is insolvent
7.478
7.479
7.480
7.481
7.482
7.483
7.484
Where insolvency depends on owing the debt claimed by the petitioner
7.485
Preventing Presentation or Continuation of a Disputed Debt Petition
Principle
7.486
7.487
7.488
7.489
7.490
7.491
7.492
7.493
7.494
7.495
7.496
7.497
7.498
7.499
Other ways of treating disputed debt petitions
7.500
7.501
7.502
7.503
7.504
7.505
Solvency of company normally irrelevant
7.506
7.507
7.508
7.509
Neglect to comply with statutory demand irrelevant
7.510
Disputed amount or timing; partially disputed debt
7.511
7.512
7.513
7.514
Cheque given for disputed debt dishonoured
7.515
Costs
7.516
7.517
7.518
7.519
7.520
7.521
Alternative basis for preventing presentation or continuation of a petition: improper pressure to pay a disputed debt
7.522
7.523
7.524
7.525
7.526
7.527
Cross-claim against Petitioner
Cross-claim greater than petitioner’s claim
7.528
7.529
7.530
What the company must prove
7.531
7.532
7.533
7.534
Test of substantiality
7.535
7.536
7.537
7.538
Special circumstances: company not trading
7.539
Special circumstances: company unable to pay petitioner’s costs of cross-claim
7.540
Special circumstances: reverse cross-claim
7.541
Special circumstances: judgment on petitioner’s claim
7.542
7.543
7.544
7.545
Special circumstances: autonomy of petitioner’s claim (pay now, argue later)
7.546
7.547
7.548
7.549
Special circumstances: company voluntary arrangement
7.550
Special circumstances: company’s hands not clean
7.551
Company’s cross-claim falls short of the petitioner’s debt by more than £750
7.552
7.553
7.554
7.555
7.556
Mutuality
7.557
7.558
7.559
Set-off
7.560
7.561
7.562
7.563
7.564
7.565
7.566
7.567
7.568
Petitioner’s standing not affected by cross-claim
7.569
Similarities between disputed debt and set-off
7.570
History
7.571
7.572
Substitution of a Disputed Creditor as Petitioner
7.573
7.574
Wasted Costs Orders
7.575
7.576
Substantiality of Ground of Dispute
The test
7.577
7.578
7.579
7.580
7.581
7.582
7.583
Evidence and onus
7.584
7.585
7.586
7.587
7.588
The court’s task
7.589
7.590
7.591
7.592
7.593
7.594
7.595
7.596
7.597
7.598
Alternative formulation of test: bona fide dispute
7.599
7.600
7.601
7.602
7.603
7.604
7.605
7.606
7.607
Alternative formulation of test: company’s defence has no rational prospect of success
7.608
7.609
7.610
Alternative formulation of test: analogy with summary judgment
7.611
7.612
7.613
7.614
7.615
7.616
7.617
7.618
7.619
7.620
Alternative formulation of test: question to be tried
7.621
7.622
7.623
7.624
7.625
Dispute must be rational
7.626
7.627
Dispute must be about the company’s liability to the petitioner
7.628
Dispute must exist now
7.629
Playing for time
7.630
7.631
7.632
7.633
7.634
Relevance of company’s solvency
7.635
Relevance of other proceedings concerning the petitioner’s debt
7.636
7.637
Judgment subject to appeal
7.638
7.639
7.640
7.641
Stay of execution
7.642
7.643
7.644
Going behind a judgment
7.645
7.646
7.647
7.648
Default and consent judgments
7.649
Relevance of creditor’s attitude to the debt
7.650
Extreme examples of insubstantial disputes
7.651
Effect of Coronavirus
7.652
Sufficient Interest of Petitioner
7.653
Exercise of Court’s Discretion
Principles on which the Discretion is Exercised
Existence of the discretion
7.654
7.655
Petition of unpaid admitted creditor
7.656
7.657
7.658
7.659
Ex debito justitiae
7.660
7.661
7.662
Class benefit
7.663
7.664
Disfavour of ex debito justitiae limitations to discretion
7.665
Opposition by Contributories or by the Company itself or its Directors
7.666
7.667
7.668
7.669
7.670
7.671
7.672
7.673
7.674
7.675
7.676
7.677
Opposition by other Creditors
Importance of other creditors’ views
7.678
7.679
7.680
7.681
Principle on which discretion is exercised
7.682
7.683
7.684
7.685
7.686
7.687
7.688
Carrying on the company’s business
7.689
7.690
7.691
7.692
7.693
7.694
7.695
More advantageous realization of assets
7.696
7.697
7.698
7.699
Administrative receivership preferred
7.700
7.701
7.702
7.703
Voluntary winding up preferred
7.704
Miscellaneous reasons for opposing a winding-up order
7.705
7.706
7.707
7.708
7.709
Discounted views of creditors connected with the company
7.710
Accepting the views of a minority opposed to a winding-up order
7.711
Choice between Winding Up and Administration
7.712
7.713
7.714
7.715
7.716
Company’s COMI in another Jurisdiction
7.717
Interests of Employees
7.718
Interests of the Public Revenue
7.719
Payment of Petitioner’s Debt
Payment before the Hearing
7.720
7.721
7.722
7.723
7.724
7.725
7.726
7.727
Payment at, or Soon after, the Hearing
7.728
7.729
7.730
Company Member of Insolvent Partnership
7.731
7.732
7.733
7.734
8 Petitions by Contributories
Preliminary Material
Standing of Contributories to Petition and Circumstances in which they may Petition
Standing
General rule
8.01
Resolution of a dispute about standing
8.02
8.03
8.04
Grounds
8.05
Partnerships
Petition by a member of a partnership
8.06
8.07
8.08
Petition by member’s insolvency office-holder
8.09
8.10
8.11
European/UK Economic Interest Groupings
8.12
Nature of Contributories’ Petitions
8.13
8.14
8.15
8.16
8.17
Which Contributories may Petition
Definition of Contributory
Registered companies
8.18
8.19
8.20
8.21
8.22
8.23
8.24
Registered companies: members under 18
8.25
Registered companies: joint members
8.26
8.27
Registered companies: conditions relating to acquisition of shares
8.28
8.29
8.30
8.31
Number of members reduced below two
8.32
8.33
Original allottee
8.34
8.35
Registered for six months
8.36
Non-shareholding member
8.37
Trustee shareholder
8.38
8.39
Building societies and incorporated friendly societies
8.40
8.41
8.42
Limited liability partnerships
8.43
8.44
Charitable incorporated organizations
8.45
Unregistered companies
8.46
8.47
8.48
Partnerships
8.49
Present Members
Registered companies
8.50
8.51
8.52
8.53
Building societies and incorporated friendly societies
8.54
Unregistered companies
8.55
Past Members
Registered companies
8.56
8.57
Building societies and incorporated friendly societies
8.58
Unregistered companies
8.59
Personal Representatives and Trustees in Bankruptcy of Members
8.60
8.61
8.62
8.63
8.64
Transferor or Beneficial Owner of Shares
8.65
8.66
8.67
Tangible Interest
Requirement
8.68
8.69
8.70
8.71
Interest in Receiving
Type of receipt
8.72
8.73
Showing probability of a distribution to contributories
8.74
8.75
Insufficient amount
8.76
8.77
8.78
8.79
8.80
Preventing Increase in Liability
Principle
8.81
Examples
8.82
8.83
Tangible Interest of Past Members
8.84
8.85
8.86
Striking Out for Lack of Tangible Interest
8.87
Alternative Dispute Resolution
Arbitration Agreement
8.88
8.89
8.90
Discretionary Stay in Favour of ADR
8.91
Grounds other than Just and Equitable
Registered Company’s Special Resolution
8.92
8.93
Public Company’s Failure to Obtain a Trading Certificate
8.94
8.95
8.96
Old Public Companies
8.97
8.98
Registered Company’s Failure to Commence Business or Suspension of Business
8.99
8.100
8.101
8.102
8.103
8.104
8.105
Inability to Pay Debts
Inability to pay debts as ground for winding up
8.106
8.107
8.108
8.109
8.110
Loss of capital
8.111
8.112
Failure of unregistered company or partnership to indemnify member
8.113
8.114
8.115
8.116
8.117
8.118
8.119
Unregistered Company Dissolved or Ceased to be a Going Concern
8.120
8.121
8.122
8.123
8.124
8.125
8.126
8.127
8.128
8.129
8.130
The Just and Equitable Clause
Principle
Statutory provisions
8.131
8.132
Nature
8.133
8.134
History
8.135
Literature
8.136
The Court’s Approach
Inference from facts
8.137
8.138
8.139
8.140
Whole picture
8.141
8.142
Balancing exercise
8.143
List of factors
8.144
8.145
Petitioner’s previous acquiescence
8.146
Last resort
8.147
Circumstances of the Company as they Affect the Petitioner
From ejusdem generis to wide generality
8.148
8.149
8.150
8.151
Limits: overlap with unfair prejudice jurisdiction
8.152
8.153
No no-fault winding up
8.154
8.155
Collateral purpose
8.156
8.157
Company in voluntary liquidation
8.158
Examples of Just and Equitable Winding Up on Contributory’s Petition
Categorization deprecated
8.159
8.160
Lines of cases identified in this work
8.161
8.162
Judicial classifications
8.163
8.164
8.165
Legislative Definitions of Circumstances
Introduction
8.166
Oppressive or unfairly prejudicial conduct (Australia, Canada)
8.167
8.168
8.169
Directors acting in their own interests (Australia, Malaysia, Singapore)
8.170
8.171
8.172
8.173
Factors not Sufficient to Justify Winding Up
Wrong done to company
8.174
8.175
8.176
8.177
8.178
Need to investigate company
8.179
Dispute which should be solved internally
8.180
8.181
8.182
Feared future events
8.183
Petitioner cannot get voluntary winding up
8.184
Petitioner’s wish to be relieved of a bad investment
8.185
8.186
Petitioner’s desire to realize investment
8.187
8.188
8.189
Removal of petitioner from directorship
8.190
Refusal to appoint petitioner a director
8.191
Connection with another company sought to be wound up
8.192
Change of company’s constitution
8.193
Petitioner’s Interest in the Company
8.194
Opposition of other Members
8.195
8.196
8.197
8.198
8.199
8.200
Drastic Character of Winding Up as a Remedy
8.201
8.202
8.203
8.204
8.205
8.206
8.207
8.208
Buying Out Petitioner
8.209
8.210
8.211
8.212
8.213
8.214
8.215
Alternative Remedies
Effect of petitioner’s failure to seek another remedy
8.216
8.217
8.218
History
8.219
Insolvent partnerships
8.220
Ordering an alternative remedy
8.221
8.222
Statutory powers to order alternative remedy on winding-up petition
8.223
Striking out for failure to seek an alternative remedy
8.224
8.225
8.226
8.227
Striking out for failure to seek unfair prejudice remedy
8.228
8.229
8.230
Offer to buy petitioner’s shares
8.231
8.232
8.233
8.234
8.235
8.236
8.237
8.238
8.239
8.240
Should the petitioner invite other members to buy shares?
8.241
Other alternative remedies
8.242
8.243
8.244
8.245
Relitigation of member’s complaints
8.246
8.247
Literature
8.248
Petitioner’s Contribution to the Situation
8.249
8.250
8.251
8.252
8.253
8.254
8.255
8.256
8.257
8.258
Fraudulent Promotion
8.259
8.260
Failure of Substratum
Principle
8.261
8.262
Types of Case
8.263
8.264
8.265
Opposition of other Members
8.266
8.267
8.268
8.269
What is the Company’s Substratum?
8.270
8.271
8.272
8.273
8.274
8.275
Miscellaneous Cases
8.276
8.277
8.278
Deadlock
Principle
8.279
8.280
8.281
What Constitutes Deadlock?
8.282
8.283
8.284
8.285
8.286
8.287
8.288
Possibility of Resolution
8.289
8.290
8.291
Petitioner’s Responsibility
8.292
Literature
8.293
Constitutional and Administrative Vacuum
8.294
8.295
8.296
8.297
8.298
Management and Conduct of Company: Oppression
Principle
8.299
8.300
8.301
8.302
Factors which Justify Winding Up
Introduction
8.303
Directors’ lack of probity
8.304
8.305
8.306
8.307
8.308
8.309
8.310
Actions not in company’s interests
8.311
8.312
8.313
Diversion of company assets
8.314
8.315
8.316
Ignoring statutory safeguards for members
8.317
8.318
8.319
Directors not providing information
8.320
Oppression
8.321
8.322
8.323
8.324
8.325
8.326
What amounts to oppression?
8.327
8.328
8.329
8.330
8.331
8.332
Mere disagreement not enough
8.333
8.334
Can a minority oppress the majority?
8.335
8.336
8.337
Controller treating the company as their own
8.338
Directors’ failure to take account of relevant matters in decision-making
8.339
Just and Equitable Winding Up of Quasi-partnership Companies
Recognition of Legitimate Expectations outside the Company’s Constitution
Legitimate expectations and quasi-partnership companies
8.340
8.341
8.342
8.343
8.344
8.345
8.346
Subjecting legal rights to equitable considerations
8.347
8.348
8.349
8.350
Principal types of case
8.351
8.352
Petitioner’s contribution to the situation
8.353
No right to a no-fault winding up
8.354
History
8.355
8.356
8.357
8.358
Literature
8.359
Determining whether a Company is a Quasi-Partnership Company
Partnership analogy
8.360
8.361
Lord Wilberforce’s factors
8.362
8.363
Members who do not take part in management
8.364
8.365
Equality of shareholding not required
8.366
Shareholders’ agreements
8.367
Extension to different company structures
8.368
8.369
8.370
Non-business companies
8.371
Death of a quasi-partner
8.372
8.373
Family company requiring mutual trust and confidence
8.374
Companies that are not quasi-partnerships
8.375
8.376
8.377
8.378
8.379
Canadian adherence to the partnership analogy
8.380
8.381
8.382
8.383
Cessation of Trust and Confidence
Principle
8.384
8.385
8.386
8.387
8.388
Impropriety not required
8.389
Unilateral loss of confidence
8.390
8.391
8.392
Examples
8.393
8.394
Deadlock
8.395
Other means of dispute resolution
8.396
Death of a quasi-partner
8.397
Extension of concept of breakdown of business relationship to non-business companies
8.398
Petitioner’s contribution to the situation
8.399
Exclusion from Management
Principle
8.400
8.401
8.402
8.403
Legitimate expectation
8.404
8.405
8.406
8.407
8.408
8.409
Resignation
8.410
Justified removal
8.411
8.412
8.413
Expulsion from a limited liability partnership
8.414
Failure of Substratum
8.415
Pre-emption Rights
8.416
Disregard of the Heir of a Member
8.417
Principle Underlying the Substratum and Quasi-partnership Cases
8.418
8.419
8.420
Miscellaneous Cases in which Winding Up may be Just and Equitable
8.421
8.422
8.423
8.424
8.425
8.426
8.427
8.428
8.429
8.430
8.431
8.432
8.433
8.434
Alternative Unfair Prejudice and Winding-up Petition
Unfair Prejudice Petitions with Alternative Application for Winding Up
8.435
8.436
8.437
8.438
8.439
8.440
8.441
8.442
Standing to Petition
Principle
8.443
8.444
Transferee or transmittee
8.445
8.446
8.447
Nominee
8.448
Former member
8.449
Disputed standing
8.450
Time limits
8.451
Meaning of ‘Interests of Members’
8.452
8.453
8.454
8.455
8.456
Meaning of ‘Unfairly Prejudicial’
8.457
8.458
8.459
8.460
8.461
8.462
8.463
Winding Up as a Statutory Oppression Remedy outside the UK
8.464
8.465
8.466
Interaction of Unfair Prejudice and Winding-up Remedies
8.467
8.468
8.469
8.470
8.471
Procedure
Applicable Rules
Contributories’ and relevant office-holders’ winding-up petitions
8.472
Members’ unfair prejudice petitions with an alternative application for winding up
8.473
8.474
Contents of Petition
Contributory’s winding-up petition
8.475
8.476
8.477
8.478
8.479
8.480
8.481
Relevant office-holder’s petition
8.482
Witness statement
8.483
Verification
8.484
Members’ unfair prejudice petitions with alternative application for winding up
8.485
8.486
8.487
8.488
8.489
8.490
Filing
Winding-up petition
8.491
Unfair prejudice petition
8.492
Fee
8.493
Fixing Return Day
8.494
8.495
Service of Petition
Contributory’s or relevant office-holder’s winding-up petition
8.496
Unfair prejudice petition
8.497
Directions
Matters on which directions will be given
8.498
8.499
Particulars or points of claim and defence
8.500
8.501
8.502
8.503
Unfair prejudice petition evidence
8.504
8.505
8.506
Notice of Petition
8.507
8.508
Certificate of Compliance
8.509
Permission to Withdraw a Petition
8.510
Substitution of Petitioner
8.511
Notice of Appearance or Permission to be Heard
8.512
Costs of Defending Petition
8.513
8.514
8.515
8.516
8.517
Representation of Company
8.518
Disclosure and Inspection of Legal Advice to Company
8.519
8.520
Use of Investigative Material in Evidence
8.521
Consent Order
8.522
Petitioner’s Costs of Successful Petition
8.523
Public Offer of Securities by Private Company
8.524
8.525
8.526
9 Public Interest Petitions
Preliminary Material
Public Interest Petitions
Winding Up in the Public Interest
Standing to petition
9.01
9.02
9.03
9.04
Secretary of State’s general power to petition in the public interest
9.05
9.06
9.07
9.08
9.09
Failure to comply with a serious crime prevention order
9.10
Powers relating to particular types of company
9.11
Secretary of State’s Decision to Present a Public Interest Petition
Investigatory processes
9.12
9.13
Confidentiality of information obtained under the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000
9.14
9.15
Who may make the decision
9.16
Judicial review of decision
9.17
Alternative proceedings
9.18
9.19
The Court’s Approach to Public Interest Petitions
Just and equitable
9.20
9.21
Public interest
9.22
9.23
9.24
Balancing exercise
9.25
9.26
9.27
Secretary of State’s evidence
9.28
9.29
9.30
9.31
9.32
9.33
Wrongdoing need not be that of the company’s directing mind
9.34
Deterrence and disapproval
9.35
9.36
9.37
9.38
9.39
Recent reform of objectionable behaviour
9.40
Undertakings
9.41
9.42
9.43
Cessation of the company’s operations
9.44
9.45
Associated companies
9.46
Aspects of Public Interest Protected
Protection from inevitable financial loss
9.47
9.48
Money circulation schemes: pyramids, snowballs and lotteries
9.49
9.50
Breach of regulatory requirements
9.51
9.52
9.53
Deceitful or misleading selling to consumers
9.54
9.55
9.56
9.57
9.58
9.59
9.60
9.61
Investor protection
9.62
9.63
Deceitful selling to business customers
9.64
Causing loss to the Crown
9.65
Other reckless, dishonest or unsatisfactory business practice
9.66
9.67
9.68
9.69
9.70
Advising or enabling clients to act unlawfully
9.71
9.72
9.73
Abuse of insolvency procedure
9.74
Companies in or Preparing for Administration
9.75
9.76
9.77
Publicity for Public Interest Petitions
9.78
9.79
9.80
9.81
9.82
9.83
9.84
9.85
9.86
9.87
Third Party Costs Orders
9.88
9.89
Literature
9.90
Other Petitions by the Secretary of State
Defunct Public Companies
9.91
Public Offer of Securities by Private Company
9.92
European/UK Economic Interest Groupings
9.93
9.94
European Public Limited-Liability Companies
9.95
Enemy Companies
9.96
9.97
9.98
9.99
9.100
Particular Types of Company: Winding Up in Public Interest
Introduction
9.101
Building Societies
9.102
9.103
9.104
9.105
9.106
Charitable Companies
9.107
9.108
9.109
9.110
Community Interest Companies
9.111
Credit Unions
9.112
9.113
Financial Services Companies and Partnerships
Authorized, PRA-authorized and PRA-regulated persons
9.114
9.115
9.116
Power to petition
9.117
9.118
9.119
9.120
9.121
9.122
9.123
9.124
Circumstances in which a winding-up order may be made
9.125
9.126
9.127
9.128
9.129
9.130
Partnerships
9.131
9.132
9.133
Residual banks and building societies
9.134
Feeder UCITS
9.135
9.136
Friendly Societies
9.137
9.138
Social Landlords
9.139
Registered Societies
9.140
9.141
10 Company Subject to Another Insolvency Procedure
Preliminary Material
Introduction
10.01
10.02
Part A1 Moratorium
10.03
10.04
10.05
Voluntary Arrangement
Company Voluntary Arrangement
10.06
10.07
10.08
10.09
10.10
Building Society Voluntary Arrangement
10.11
Charitable Incorporated Organizations
10.12
Limited Liability Partnerships
10.13
Insolvent Partnerships
Moratorium for preparation of partnership voluntary arrangement
10.14
10.15
Failure of moratorium to produce voluntary arrangement
10.16
10.17
Petition by a partnership’s voluntary arrangement supervisor for its winding up
10.18
10.19
10.20
Ineligibility for Part A1 Moratorium
10.21
Conversion of Secondary Proceedings
10.22
Administration
Schedule B1 Administration
Interim moratorium
10.23
10.24
10.25
10.26
Companies in administration
10.27
10.28
10.29
Suspended petition
10.30
Petition by a company’s administrator for it to be wound up
10.31
10.32
10.33
10.34
Ending administration on administrator’s application
10.35
10.36
Moving from administration to dissolution
10.37
Limited liability partnerships
10.38
Special Administration Regimes
Protection from winding up
10.39
Interim moratorium
10.40
10.41
10.42
10.43
During special administration
10.44
10.45
10.46
10.47
10.48
10.49
Petition or application by a company’s special administrator for its winding up
10.50
10.51
10.52
10.53
10.54
10.55
10.56
10.57
Partnership Administration
10.58
10.59
10.60
Conversion of Secondary Proceedings
10.61
Default Rules of Recognized Bodies
10.62
Administrative Receivership
10.63
10.64
10.65
10.66
Receivership
10.67
10.68
Lloyd’s Reorganization
Winding Up of Member or Former Member of Lloyd’s
10.69
10.70
10.71
10.72
10.73
Winding Up of Lloyd’s
10.74
Voluntary Winding Up
Voluntary Winding Up no Bar to Winding Up by the Court
Standing to petition not affected by voluntary winding up
10.75
Choice between voluntary and compulsory winding up
10.76
10.77
10.78
Replacing voluntary liquidator a suitable alternative remedy
10.79
10.80
Official receiver’s standing to petition
10.81
10.82
Voluntary liquidator
10.83
Literature
10.84
Superfluous provision
10.85
10.86
10.87
Validity of voluntary winding up
10.88
10.89
10.90
10.91
Unregistered companies
10.92
Building societies
10.93
Incorporated friendly societies
10.94
Creditor’s Petition
Standing of creditors to petition
10.95
No objection by other creditors
10.96
10.97
Views of other creditors
10.98
10.99
10.100
Majority opposing winding up by the court
10.101
10.102
Need for investigation and doubts about voluntary liquidator’s impartiality: suitable alternative remedy
10.103
10.104
10.105
10.106
10.107
Majority support for winding up by the court
10.108
10.109
Former requirement to show prejudice to petitioner
10.110
10.111
10.112
10.113
10.114
10.115
10.116
10.117
Contributory’s Petition
Prejudice to rights of contributories must be shown
10.118
10.119
10.120
Cases before the statutory condition was introduced
10.121
10.122
10.123
10.124
10.125
Public Interest Petitions
10.126
10.127
10.128
10.129
Official Receiver’s Petition
10.130
10.131
10.132
10.133
10.134
Other Petitioners
10.135
10.136
10.137
Confirmation by the Court
10.138
10.139
10.140
10.141
10.142
10.143
Voluntary Winding Up Subject to Supervision of Court
Availability of supervision orders
10.144
10.145
10.146
10.147
Supervision and winding up by the court compared
10.148
10.149
Application procedure
10.150
Petition asking only for supervision order
10.151
Petition asking for winding-up order or such other order as would be just
10.152
10.153
Court’s discretion
10.154
Views of creditors and contributories
10.155
10.156
10.157
Voluntary winding up void
10.158
Company being Wound Up by the Court
10.159
10.160
10.161
Bank Insolvency
10.162
Office Holders as Creditors
10.163
Insolvency Procedures Elsewhere in United Kingdom
Jurisdiction of English Court to Order Winding Up
10.164
10.165
Enforcing Orders Made in Scotland and Northern Ireland
10.166
Assisting Courts in Scotland and Northern Ireland
10.167
10.168
10.169
Meaning of ‘Insolvency Law’
10.170
10.171
10.172
Insolvency Procedures outside United Kingdom
Assisting Foreign Courts: Common Law
10.173
10.174
Assisting the Courts of Relevant Countries and Territories
10.175
10.176
10.177
10.178
10.179
Jurisdiction to Wind Up a Company being Wound Up outside the United Kingdom
10.180
10.181
10.182
10.183
Main Proceedings in Foreign EU State (apart from Denmark)
Request to open secondary proceedings
10.184
10.185
10.186
10.187
10.188
Secondary proceedings avoided by undertaking
10.189
10.190
Great Britain Version of the UNCITRAL Model Law
Scope of the Great Britain version of the UNCITRAL Model Law
10.191
10.192
10.193
10.194
10.195
10.196
10.197
Companies excluded
10.198
Interaction with Regulation (EU) 2015/848
10.199
Foreign Representative’s Standing to Petition
10.200
10.201
10.202
10.203
Recognition of a Foreign Proceeding
Principle
10.204
Court
10.205
10.206
Form of recognition order
10.207
Effects of recognition
10.208
10.209
10.210
Foreign Winding-up Application and Related English Proceedings: Election
10.211
11 Other Petitioners
Preliminary Material
Company’s Petition for its Own Winding Up
Power to Petition
11.01
11.02
11.03
Grounds
Available grounds
11.04
Resolution to be wound up
11.05
11.06
11.07
Authority of Directors to Present Company’s Petition
11.08
11.09
11.10
11.11
11.12
Insolvency Office-holders
11.13
Corporate Member of Insolvent Partnership
11.14
Directors’ Petition
Registered and Unregistered Companies
11.15
11.16
11.17
11.18
Open-Ended Investment Companies
11.19
Fine Collection
11.20
11.21
Further Material
Index
Sign up for alerts
7 Petitions by Creditors
From:
Applications to Wind up Companies (4th Edition)
Derek French
Edited By: Stuart Sime
Content type:
Book content
Product:
Financial Law [FBL]
Published in print:
25 March 2021
ISBN:
9780198869726
Prev
|
Next