We use cookies to enhance your experience on our website. By continuing to use our website, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. You can change your cookie settings at any time.
Find out more
Jump to Content
Jump to Main Navigation
User Account
Personal Profile
See all online law products
More
About
Guided Tour
Subscriber Services
Contact Us
FAQ
Help
Search
Browse all
Area of law
Financial Law [FBL]
International Commercial Arbitration [ICMA]
Private International Law [PRIL]
International Commercial Law [ICML]
Author
My Content
(0)
Recently viewed
(0)
Save Entry
My Searches
(0)
Recently viewed
(0)
Save Search
Print
Save
Cite
Email this content
Share Link
Copy this link, or click below to email it to a friend
Email this content
or copy the link directly:
https://olrl.ouplaw.com/abstract/10.1093/law/9780198702627.001.0001/law-9780198702627-chapter-200
The link was not copied. Your current browser may not support copying via this button.
Link copied successfully
Copy link
Sign in
You could not be signed in, please check and try again.
Username
Please enter your Username
Password
Please enter your Password
Forgot password?
Don't have an account?
Sign in via your Institution
You could not be signed in, please check and try again.
Sign in with your library card
Please enter your library card number
View translated passages only
Oxford Law Citator
Contents
Expand All
Collapse All
Preliminary Material
Dedication
Suggested form of citation:
Preface to the Second Edition
Preface to the First Edition
Contents
List of Contributors
Abbreviations
Table of Transnational Instruments
European Union Treaties
Regulations
Directives
Table of National Instruments
Argentina
Austria
Belgium
Brazil
Canada
Chile
Cuba
Czech Republic
Czechoslovakia
Denmark
Estonia
France
German Democratic Republic
Germany
Greece
Israel
Italy
Japan
Korea
Latvia
Liberia
Libya
Lithuania
Luxembourg
Netherlands
New Zealand
Nordic Countries
Panama
Paraguay
People’s Republic of China
Poland
Portugal
Republic of Côte d’Ivoire
Romania
Russian Federation
Scandinavia
Serbia
Singapore
Slovak Republic
Spain
Sweden
Switzerland
Turkey
Ukraine
United Kingdom
Statutory Instruments
USA
Venezuela
Vietnam
Table of Cases
Arbitral Tribunals
CIETAC
ICACRF
ICC
ICSID
LCIA
PCA
Other Tribunals
Court Decisions
Court of Justice of the European Union
Argentina
Australia
Austria
Belgium
Brazil
Canada
China
Colombia
Denmark
France
Germany
India
Italy
Kenya
Lithuania
Netherlands
New Zealand
Norway
Paraguay
Poland
Portugal
Russian Federation
Singapore
Slovenia
South Africa
Spain
Sweden
Switzerland
Ukraine
United Kingdom
USA
Venezuela
UNIDROIT Principles of International Commercial Contracts (2010): Full Text in all Official Language Versions
Table of Correspondence of the Articles of the 1994, 2004, and 2010 Editions of the PICC
General Bibliography
Main Text
Introduction
Introductory Material
Preliminary Material
I Background
1
1 Perceived need for harmonization of the law of international commercial contracts
2
3
4
5
6
2 Tools of harmonization
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
II Genesis
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
III Structure, presentation, and style
32
33
34
35
36
37
IV Content
38
39
40
41
42
43
V Reception
44
45
46
47
48
49
VI Outlook
1 Substantive changes
50
51
52
53
54
2 Promoting the use of the PICC in legal practice
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
Preamble I
Purposes, legal nature, and scope of the PICC; applicability by courts; use of the PICC for the purpose of interpretation and supplementation and as a model
Preliminary Material
Selected bibliography
Preamble
I Purposes and legal nature of the PICC
1
2
1 The PICC as a restatement: the description of a common core
3
4
2 The PICC as a model: the prescription of potentially binding rules
5
6
3 The PICC as effective law: the prescription of actually binding rules
7
8
4 The PICC as a background law
9
II Scope of the PICC (paragraph 1 of the Preamble)
1 The function of paragraph 1
10
11
2 ‘Rules’
12
13
3 ‘General’
(a) Not specific to individual countries
14
15
16
17
(b) General contract law
18
(c) General character of rules
19
4 ‘Contracts’
20
21
5 ‘International’
22
23
24
25
6 ‘Commercial’
26
27
28
29
III Applicability by courts (paragraphs 2–4 of the Preamble)
30
1 The function of paragraphs 2–4
31
32
2 Applicability as law chosen by the parties (paragraph 2 of the Preamble)
(a) Different ways of choosing the PICC
(1) The PICC as applicable law under choice of law
33
(2) The PICC as incorporated into the contract under substantive law
34
35
36
(3) The PICC as agreed rules under procedural freedom of disposal
37
(b) Effects of choice
(1) Differences in result
38
39
(2) Selection of the PICC
40
41
42
(3) Deselecting rules of otherwise applicable law
43
44
45
(4) Need of supplementation
46
(c) Personal and temporal applicability
(1) Personal applicability: multi-party relations
47
(2) Intertemporal applicability: the applicable edition of the PICC
48
(d) Evaluation
49
50
51
(e) Choice of law clause
52
53
54
55
56
57
(f) Solutions under existing legal regimes
(1) General comparative results
58
59
(2) Global unification
60
61
62
(3) European Union
63
64
65
66
(4) Other European countries
67
68
(5) North America
69
70
71
(6) Latin America
72
73
74
(7) Africa and Arab countries
75
(8) Asia
76
(9) Pacific
77
3 The PICC as general principles of law or lex mercatoria (paragraph 3 of the Preamble)
78
79
80
81
4 Applicability without a choice by the parties (paragraph 4 of the Preamble)
(a) The PICC as objective substantive law
82
83
84
(b) Solutions under existing conflict of laws regimes
(1) General comparative results
85
86
(2) European Union
87
88
(3) Other European countries
89
(4) North America
90
91
92
93
94
(4) Latin America
95
96
(5) Asia
97
5 Application where choice of law rules do not yield results
98
(a) Application when it cannot be determined what law applies
99
(b) Application when the content of the applicable law cannot be established
100
101
102
103
6 Application as trade usage or custom
104
105
106
107
VI Use for the purposes of interpretation and supplementation (paragraphs 5–6 of the Preamble)
1 International uniform laws (paragraph 5 of the Preamble)
(a) General issues
(1) Interpretation
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
(2) Supplementation
116
117
(3) General part of uniform contract law
118
(4) Party determination
119
(b) Specific applications
(1) The CISG and other UNCITRAL Conventions
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
(2) Other conventions
128
129
130
131
(3) European Union law
132
133
2 Domestic law (paragraph 6 of the Preamble)
134
135
136
137
138
139
140
3 Contracts
141
142
V Use as a model (paragraph 7 of the Preamble)
1 Legislation
143
144
(a) Global unification
145
146
147
148
(b) Regional unification
(1) Organization for the Harmonization of Business Law in Africa (OHADA)
149
150
151
(2) Others
152
153
154
155
(c) National legislation
156
(1) Europe
157
158
159
160
161
162
(2) The Americas
163
(3) Asia-Pacific
164
165
166
(4) Africa
167
2 Contract drafting
168
169
170
171
172
173
3 Mediation and conciliation
174
4 Legal education
175
176
Preamble II
The use of the PICC in arbitration
Preliminary Material
Selected bibliography
I Application of the PICC as the lex contractus
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
1 Agreement of the parties on their contract being governed by the PICC
8
(a) Choice of law clause in favour of the PICC
9
(b) Choice of law clause referring to both the PICC and a domestic law
10
11
12
13
(c) Choice of law clause referring to the terms of the contract supplemented by the PICC
14
2 References to general principles of law, lex mercatoria , or usages
15
(a) Clauses in favour of ‘general principles of law, the lex mercatoria or the like’
16
17
18
19
20
(b) Clauses in favour of ‘usages’ or ‘international trade usages’
21
22
23
3 Application of the PICC when the parties have not chosen any law to govern their contract
24
(a) The PICC as the lex contractus where there is no choice of law
25
26
27
28
29
30
(b) The PICC as the lex contractus where there is a negative choice of law
31
32
33
34
35
36
(c) The PICC as the lex contractus in the case of simultaneous designation of two or more domestic laws
37
38
4 Choice of law other than the PICC
39
40
41
42
II Use of the PICC to supplement or interpret the lex contractus
43
1 Use of the PICC to interpret or supplement international uniform law
44
45
2 Use of the PICC to interpret or supplement the applicable domestic law
46
(a) Use of the PICC by arbitrators to supplement or interpret domestic law
47
48
49
50
51
(b) Use of the PICC to ‘interpret’ or ‘supplement’ the applicable domestic law
52
53
54
55
56
57
III Use of the PICC by arbitral tribunals in situations not dealt with in the Preamble
58
59
60
61
62
63
IV The role of the PICC where arbitrators decide ex aequo et bono
64
65
66
V Challenge and enforcement of an arbitral award based on the PICC rather than on a domestic law
67
68
69
1 Reliance on the PICC in the absence of a choice of law clause is not a ground for annulment or denial of enforcement per se
70
(a) Challenge of awards
71
72
73
74
75
(b) Recognition and enforcement of awards
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
2 Application of the PICC and due process
83
VI Application of the PICC to arbitration agreements
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
Ch.1 General Provisions
Introduction to Chapter 1 of the PICC
Preliminary Material
I A Chapter on ‘general provisions’
1
2
3
4
II Structure of Chapter 1
5
6
7
8
III Evaluation
9
10
11
General Provisions I: Arts 1.1–1.3—Fundamental principles
Preliminary Material
Selected bibliography
Art.1.1
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
3
4
II Freedom to contract
5
6
7
III Freedom to determine the content of the contract
8
9
10
Art.1.2
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
3
4
II Scope of application of Art 1.2
5
6
7
8
III Relevant formal requirements
1 Mandatory formal requirements
9
10
2 Formal requirements agreed by the parties
11
12
13
3 ‘Writing’
14
15
16
17
Art.1.3
Preliminary Material
I Bindingness of contract
1
2
3
4
5
II Implications
6
7
III Exceptions
8
9
General Provisions II: Arts 1.4–1.5—Mandatory rules
Preliminary Material
Selected bibliography
Art.1.4
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
3
4
II Relevant rules of private international law
5
6
1 Courts
7
8
2 Arbitral tribunals
(a) The PICC can be chosen as rules of law governing a contract
9
10
(b) International mandatory rules in international arbitration
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
(c) Transnational public policy
18
19
20
III Origin of mandatory rules
21
22
Art.1.5
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
II Complete exclusion of the application of the PICC
3
4
III Derogation from or variation of particular provisions of the PICC
5
6
IV Providing for the application of several legal regimes ( depeçage )
7
8
9
10
V Mandatory provisions of the PICC
11
12
13
General Provisions III: Arts 1.6–1.12—Application of the PICC
Preliminary Material
Selected bibliography
Art.1.6
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
3
II Interpretation of the PICC, Art 1.6(1)
4
1 General guidelines for the interpretation of the PICC
(a) International character and autonomous interpretation of the PICC
5
6
7
8
(b) Uniform application of the PICC
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
2 Criteria of interpretation
20
(a) Text
21
22
(b) Context
23
24
25
26
27
(c) Drafting history
28
29
30
(d) Purposes
31
32
(e) Policy arguments
33
34
35
36
3 Weight of the interpretative criteria
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
III Supplementation of the PICC, Art 1.6(2)
44
45
1 Issues within the scope of the PICC but not expressly settled by them
46
47
48
49
50
2 ‘Settling the issue’
51
(a) Recourse to underlying general principles and other interpretative criteria
52
53
54
55
(b) Analogy
56
57
(c) Recourse to another law
58
59
Art.1.7
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
3
4
5
II Scope of the obligation to act in accordance with good faith and fair dealing
1 ‘Bona fide purchasers’ not covered
6
2 A general obligation and its specific applications
7
8
9
10
III Standard of good faith and fair dealing
11
12
1 An ethical standard
13
2 A standard employed ‘in international trade’
14
15
16
17
3 Meaning of ‘good faith and fair dealing’
(a) Language, context, and drafting history of Art 1.7
18
19
(b) International context of Art 1.7
20
21
(c) Case law under Art 1.7
22
23
24
25
(d) Function of the standard of good faith and fair dealing under Art 1.7
26
27
28
29
IV Practical relevance of Art 1.7
30
31
32
33
1 Abuse of rights
34
35
2 Trifling matters may be excepted from the application of the rule ( de minimis non curat lex )
36
37
V Consequences of failure to act in accordance with good faith and fair dealing
38
39
40
VI No exclusion or limitation of the obligation, Art 1.7(2)
41
42
43
VII Burden of proof
44
Art.1.8
Preliminary Material
I Sanctioning inconsistent behaviour as a general principle of law
1
II Relationship between Arts 1.8 and 1.7
2
3
4
III Requirements
1 One party causing an understanding in another party
5
6
7
8
2 The other party reasonably acting in reliance on the understanding
9
10
3 Inconsistent behaviour of the first party
11
4 Detriment to the other party
12
IV Remedies
13
14
15
V Exclusions or limitations of Art 1.8
16
Art.1.9
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
3
II Usages and practices established between the parties
1 Usages
4
5
6
2 Practices established between the parties
7
III Bindingness of usages and practices
8
1 Practices established between the parties
9
2 Usages
(a) Usages agreed between the parties
10
(b) Other usages
11
(1) Regular observance in international trade
12
13
14
15
(2) Wide knowledge
16
17
18
(3) Application not unreasonable
19
20
3 Binding force
21
22
IV Burden of proof
23
Art.1.10
Preliminary Material
I Rationale of Art 1.10
1
II Notice
2
3
4
5
III Effectiveness
1 Means of communication
6
7
8
9
2 Receipt
10
11
12
13
3 Abusive prevention of giving notice
14
4 Comprehensibility of notice
15
16
5 Agreed requirements for the effectiveness of notices
17
6 Withdrawal of notice
18
IV Burden of proof
19
Art.1.11
Preliminary Material
1
2
3
Art.1.12
Preliminary Material
I Computation of time and periods in general
1
2
3
II Implications of holidays and non-business days
4
5
6
7
III Time zones and hour format
8
9
Ch.2 Formation and authority of agents
s.1: Formation
Preliminary Material
Selected bibliography on offer and acceptance
Introduction to Arts 2.1.1–2.1.14
Preliminary Material
I General themes
1
2
3
II Formation in modern commercial practice
4
5
6
7
8
III The PICC and modern commercial practice
9
10
11
12
13
14
IV Electronic signatures
15
16
17
V Letters of intent
18
VI Notices
19
Formation I: Arts 2.1.1–2.1.5—Offer
Art.2.1.1
Preliminary Material
I Introduction and burden of proof
1
2
3
4
II Conduct sufficient to show agreement
5
6
7
8
9
III Offer and acceptance
10
11
Art.2.1.2
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
3
4
II Intention to be bound
5
1 Public proposals, tenders, quotes, letters of intent or comfort
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
2 Lack of intention expressed or known
15
16
17
III Sufficient definiteness
18
19
20
21
Art.2.1.3
Preliminary Material
I Communication and effectiveness of an offer
1
2
3
4
II Withdrawal of an offer
5
6
7
8
9
III Burden of proof
10
IV Reform proposal
11
12
Art.2.1.4
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
3
4
II Notice of revocation
5
6
7
8
III Revocability
9
1 Irrevocability indicated by the offer
10
11
12
13
14
15
2 Irrevocability due to reasonable reliance
16
17
18
19
IV Reform proposal
20
Art.2.1.5
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
II Termination of offer by explicit or implied rejection
3
4
5
III Termination of offer by other means
6
7
Formation II: Arts 2.1.6–2.1.14—Acceptance
Art.2.1.6
Preliminary Material
I Acceptance
1
2
3
4
5
II Indication of assent
1 Explicit indication of assent
6
7
8
2 Implicit indication of assent
9
10
11
3 Silence or inactivity as acceptance
(a) General rule
12
13
(b) Exceptions
14
15
16
17
18
19
III Effectiveness of acceptance
1 Rule: receipt of indication of assent
20
21
2 Delivery and receipt
22
3 When control equals receipt
23
24
25
26
4 Electronic communications
27
5 Exception: formation by conduct without knowledge of the offeror
28
29
30
31
IV Order of communications and labels
32
V Burden of proof
33
Art.2.1.7
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
II Time of acceptance fixed by the offeror
2
3
III Default time of acceptance
4
1 Acceptance of oral offers
5
6
2 Acceptance inter absentes
7
8
9
IV Burden of proof
10
Art.2.1.8
Preliminary Material
1
2
3
4
Art.2.1.9
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
II Lateness attributable to offeree
1 No reaction, no contract
3
2 Offeror becomes master of acceptance
4
3 Reaction without undue delay
5
6
4 Burden of proof
7
III Delays in transmission
8
1 Irregular delay in transmission
9
10
11
2 Rejection of late acceptance
12
3 Burden of proof
13
Art.2.1.10
Preliminary Material
1
2
3
Art.2.1.11
Preliminary Material
I Rule: modified acceptance as counter-offer
1
2
3
II Exception: non-material alterations
4
1 Background
5
6
2 Materiality of alterations
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
3 Consequences
14
15
16
III Burden of proof
17
Art.2.1.12
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
3
II Silence as acceptance of new terms
4
5
6
7
8
III Standard terms
9
1 Incorporation
10
2 Arbitration clauses
11
12
IV Consequences
13
14
15
16
V Burden of proof
17
Art.2.1.13
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
II Conditional contracts compared
2
III Fundamental prerequisites
3
4
5
IV Particular formalities
6
7
8
9
Art.2.1.14
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
II Present intention to be bound despite open terms
3
4
III Open terms to be subsequently agreed
1 Intention to be bound
5
6
2 Examples of open terms in enforceable contracts
7
8
9
3 The fate of the contract on a failure of negotiations
10
11
12
13
4 Hybrid application and automatic termination
14
IV Resolving disputes on open terms
15
16
17
V Burden of proof
18
19
Formation III: Arts 2.1.15–2.1.16—Negotiations
Preliminary Material
Selected bibliography
Art.2.1.15
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1 Recognition of pre-contractual liability
1
2
3
4
5
2 Nature of the liability
6
3 The practical relevance of Art 2.1.15
7
8
9
10
11
12
II Freedom to negotiate
13
14
15
III Liability arising in the pre-contractual sphere
16
1 General requirements for liability
(a) The negotiation period
17
(b) Bad faith in the negotiation process
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
2 Specific heads of liability
25
(a) Negotiating in bad faith
26
27
28
29
30
(b) Breaking off negotiations in bad faith
31
32
33
(1) Circumstances of the case
34
35
36
37
(2) The level of agreement achieved by the negotiating parties
38
39
(c) Other possible cases of pre-contractual liability
(1) Renegotiations
40
(2) Cases falling under Art 2.1.13 or Art 2.1.14 PICC
41
IV Consequences
1 Damages
42
43
2 Right to performance
44
45
V Exclusion or limitation of liability
46
47
VI Burden of proof
48
Art.2.1.16
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1 Recognition of the duty of confidentiality
1
2
3
2 Nature of the liability
4
3 Practical relevance
5
6
7
II Duty of confidentiality
1 No duty of confidentiality in principle
8
2 Source of the duty
9
(a) An agreement of confidentiality
10
(b) An implied duty of confidentiality
11
3 Confidential information
12
13
4 Content of the duty and breach
14
15
(a) Disclosure of confidential information
16
(b) Improper use for its own purposes
17
III Consequences of breaches of the duty
18
19
20
21
22
IV Burden of proof
23
Formation IV: Arts 2.1.17–2.1.18—Integrity of writing
Art.2.1.17
Preliminary Material
I Merger clauses
1
2
II Validity and effect of merger clauses
3
4
5
6
7
Art.2.1.18
Preliminary Material
I ‘No oral modification’ clauses
1
2
3
II Validity and effect of ‘no oral modification’ clauses
4
5
6
III Exceptions
7
8
9
10
11
Formation V: Arts 2.1.19–2.1.22—Standard terms
Preliminary Material
Selected bibliography
Introduction to Arts 2.1.19–2.1.22
1
2
3
4
Art.2.1.19
Preliminary Material
I Definition of ‘standard terms’
1
2
3
4
5
II General rules on formation apply
6
7
8
9
III Express incorporation
10
1 Standard terms contained in the contractual document
11
2 Standard terms contained in a separate document, electronic file, or on the reverse of a contractual document
(a) Express reference normally required
12
13
14
15
(b) Obligation to take reasonable steps to bring contents of terms to attention of other party
16
17
18
(1) Obligation to make text of standard terms available where reasonable
19
20
21
22
23
(2) Sometimes mere reference together with a preparedness to convey the text on request is sufficient
24
25
26
27
IV Implied incorporation
28
1 Incorporation by usage
29
30
2 Incorporation by practice
31
32
33
V Special requirements for incorporation of arbitration and jurisdiction clauses
34
Art.2.1.20
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
3
4
II ‘Surprising terms’
5
1 Terms surprising by virtue of their content
(a) Basic test
6
(b) Typical fact patterns
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
2 Terms ‘surprising’ by virtue of their language or presentation
14
15
16
III Express acceptance of surprising terms required
17
18
IV Burden of proof
19
Art.2.1.21
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
II ‘A term which is not a standard term’
3
4
5
6
7
8
III ‘Conflict’
9
IV Burden of proof
10
Art.2.1.22
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
II Battle of forms and the general rules on offer and acceptance
2
III Requirements for application of the knock-out rule
3
4
5
6
IV Result of applying the knock-out rule
7
8
9
V Battle of conflicting choice of law clauses and jurisdiction clauses
10
VI Other possible solutions to the battle of forms and the case for the knock-out doctrine
11
12
13
14
15
s.2: Authority of agents
Preliminary Material
Selected bibliography
Art.2.2.1
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
3
4
II Scope of Section 2.2 of the PICC
5
6
III No definition of ‘agent’
7
IV Legal relations ‘by or with respect to a contract’
8
9
V Authority to affect the legal relations of another person
10
11
VI Agent acting in its own name or in that of the principal
12
VII Internal aspects of agency
13
14
VIII Agency by operation of law excluded
15
Art.2.2.2
Preliminary Material
I Structure of Art 2.2.2
1
II Establishment of authority
2
1 Express grant of authority
3
4
2 Implied grant of authority
5
III Scope of authority
1 Express grant of authority
6
7
2 Implied grant of authority
8
9
10
11
12
IV Burden of proof
13
Art.2.2.3
Preliminary Material
I Structure of Art 2.2.3
1
2
3
4
II Requirements of disclosed agency
1 Acting within scope of authority
5
2 Publicity
6
7
8
9
III Consequences of disclosed agency
10
11
12
13
14
15
IV Burden of proof
16
Art.2.2.4
Preliminary Material
I Drafting background
1
2
3
4
II Practical consequences of (attempted) undisclosed agency
5
6
7
8
9
III Enterprise liability
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
IV Burden of proof
17
18
Art.2.2.5
Preliminary Material
I Agent acting without authority
1
2
II Apparent authority
3
4
1 Requirements of apparent authority
5
6
(a) Express representation by the principal
7
(b) Implicit representation by the principal
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
(c) Representations by the agent
15
16
(d) Negligent omission on the part of the principal
17
(e) Knowledge of the third party
18
2 Consequences of apparent authority
19
20
III Burden of proof
21
Art.2.2.6
Preliminary Material
I Extent of false agent’s liability
1
2
3
4
5
II Third party’s knowledge of agent’s lack of authority
6
7
III Burden of proof
8
Art.2.2.7
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
3
4
5
II ‘Conflict of interests’
6
7
8
III Consent to or knowledge of conflict of interests by principal
9
10
11
IV Burden of proof
12
Art.2.2.8
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
II Requirements of sub-agency
3
4
5
6
7
8
III Consequences of delegation
9
10
11
12
IV Burden of proof
13
Art.2.2.9
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
II Prerequisites of ratification
3
4
5
6
III Requirements for ratification
7
8
9
10
11
12
IV Effects of ratification
13
14
15
16
17
18
V Burden of proof
19
20
Art.2.2.10
Preliminary Material
I Grounds for termination
1
2
II Termination and apparent authority
3
4
5
III Authority of necessity
6
7
IV Burden of proof
8
Ch.3 Validity
Introduction to Chapter 3 of the PICC
1
Selected bibliography on validity in general and grounds for avoidance
s.1: General provisions
Art.3.1.1
Preliminary Material
I Purpose of Art 3.1.1
1
2
3
4
II Lack of capacity
5
6
7
III Law applicable to issues of validity excluded from the scope of application of the PICC
8
Art.3.1.2
Preliminary Material
I Purpose of Art 3.1.2
1
2
II Mere agreement
3
III No further requirements
4
1 Exclusion of requirements of consideration and cause
(a) General rule
5
6
7
(b) Consideration and enforceability of the contract
8
(c) Cause and illegality/immorality
9
2 Exclusion of the doctrine of the real contract
10
11
IV No application of Art 3.1.2 to formal requirements
12
Art.3.1.3
Preliminary Material
I Purpose of Art 3.1.3
1
2
3
II Initial impossibility of performance
1 Concept of initial impossibility
4
2 Performance initially unreasonably burdensome or expensive
5
III Lack of legal title
6
7
IV Scope of Art 3.1.3
1 Irrelevance of the doctrinal construction in domestic law
8
2 Art 3.1.3 does not cover other domestic rules on invalidity
9
10
Art.3.1.4
Preliminary Material
I Application
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
II Basis for mandatory character
9
10
11
s.2: Grounds for avoidance
Art.3.2.1
Preliminary Material
I Purpose of Art 3.2.1
1
2
II Erroneous assumption relating to facts or to law
3
4
5
6
7
8
III Relevant time
9
10
IV Burden of proof
11
V Consequences
12
Art.3.2.2
Preliminary Material
I Purpose of Art 3.2.2
1
2
3
4
II Seriousness of mistake, Art 3.2.2(1)
5
6
7
8
III Other party not worthy of protection, Art 3.2.2(1)(a) and (b)
9
1 Common mistake
10
11
12
2 Mistake caused by the other party
13
14
15
16
17
3 Violation of duty to inform the mistaken party
18
(a) ‘Knew or ought to have known’
19
(b) Breach of duty to inform the mistaken party
20
21
4 No acting in reliance on the contract ( res integra ), Art 3.2.2(1)(b)
22
23
24
25
26
IV Mistaken party not worthy of protection, Art 3.2.2(2)
27
1 Gross negligence of the mistaken party, Art 3.2.2(2)(a)
28
2 Allocation of risk, Art 3.2.2(2)(b)
29
(a) Assumption of risk
30
31
32
33
34
(b) Risk to be borne by mistaken party
35
36
37
38
39
40
V Specific cases
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
VI Burden of proof
48
VII Consequences of relevant mistake
49
Art.3.2.3
Preliminary Material
I Purpose of Art 3.2.3
1
2
3
II Error in expression or in transmission
1 Error in expression
4
2 Error in transmission
5
6
7
III Right to avoid the contract
1 General principles
8
9
10
11
12
2 Specific fact patterns
(a) Error in calculation
13
14
15
(b) Signing an unread document
16
3 Burden of proof
17
IV Damages under Art 3.2.16
18
Art.3.2.4
Preliminary Material
I Purpose of Art 3.2.4
1
2
3
4
II Requirements for exclusion of the right to avoid for mistake
5
6
7
8
III Consequences
9
IV Burden of proof
10
Art.3.2.5
Preliminary Material
I The relationship between fraud and mistake
1
2
3
4
5
II The requirements for fraud
1 State of mind: fraudulent intention
6
7
8
9
2 Conduct
10
(a) Fraudulent representation
11
12
13
(b) Fraudulent non-disclosure
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
3 Causality: a party must be ‘led to conclude the contract’ by the representation
23
24
4 Burden of proof
25
III The consequences of fraud
1 Avoidance and restitution
26
2 Damages
27
IV Fraud and third parties
28
29
V Exclusion of liability
30
Art.3.2.6
Preliminary Material
I The requirements for the threat
1 The threat must be ‘unjustified’
1
2
3
4
5
(a) The threatened act or omission which is wrongful in itself
6
7
8
9
(b) The threatened act or omission which it is wrongful to use as a means to obtain the conclusion of the contract
10
11
2 The threat must be so imminent and serious as to leave the first party no reasonable alternative
12
13
14
3 The threat must lead the party to conclude the contract
15
16
17
4 Burden of proof
18
II The consequences of the threat
1 Avoidance and restitution
19
2 Damages
20
III Threats and third parties
21
22
23
IV Exclusion of liability
24
Art.3.2.7
Preliminary Material
I Background and general purpose
1
2
3
4
5
6
II The requirements for gross disparity
1 Giving an excessive advantage
7
8
2 In an unjustifiable manner
9
(a) Taking unfair advantage of certain forms of weakness
10
11
12
13
14
(b) The nature and purpose of the contract
15
16
17
(c) Other factors
18
3 Burden of proof
19
III The consequences of gross disparity
1 Avoidance and restitution
20
2 Adaptation
21
22
3 Damages
23
IV Third parties
24
25
V Exclusion of liability
26
Art.3.2.8
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
3
II Invalidity when the other party is ‘responsible’ for the acts of the third party
1 General purpose and application of Art 3.2.8(1)
4
2 Being responsible for the acts of the third party
5
6
7
8
3 The imputability of the grounds for invalidity to a third person, or that person’s knowledge or deemed knowledge of the grounds for invalidity
9
10
III Third persons for whom the other party is not responsible
1 General purpose and application of Art 3.2.8(2)
11
12
13
2 The imputability of the grounds for invalidity to a third person
14
3 Knowledge or deemed knowledge of grounds for invalidity, or not reasonably acting in reliance on the contract
15
(a) The other party knows or ought to have known of the fraud, threat, or disparity
16
17
18
(b) The other party did not reasonably act in reliance on the contract
19
IV Other three-party situations
20
21
Art.3.2.9
Preliminary Material
I Purpose of Art 3.2.9
1
2
3
II Requirements
1 Ground for avoidance
4
2 Express or implied confirmation
5
6
7
8
3 Time for confirmation
9
III Effect of confirmation
10
11
Art.3.2.10
Preliminary Material
I Purpose of Art 3.2.10
1
2
II Requirements
1 Mistake as ground for avoidance
3
2 Willingness of the other party to adapt the contract to the understanding of the mistaken party
4
5
6
7
3 Irrelevant whether notice already given
8
III Consequences
9
10
11
Art.3.2.11
Preliminary Material
I Purpose of Art 3.2.11
1
II Scope of application
2
III Notice
3
4
IV No duty on the other party to reply
5
Art.3.2.12
Preliminary Material
I Purpose of Art 3.2.12
1
II Commencement
2
3
4
5
III Duration
6
7
IV Consequences of failure to avoid within time limit
8
9
Art.3.2.13
Preliminary Material
I Ground of avoidance restricted to individual terms of the contract
1
2
II Partial avoidance unless unreasonable
1 Partial avoidance as general rule
3
2 Avoidance of entire contract as exception
4
5
6
7
8
3 Partial avoidance and restitution
9
Art.3.2.14
Preliminary Material
I The effect of retroactive avoidance in general
1
II The effect on the contractual obligations
1 Unfulfilled and unaffected obligations
2
3
4
2 Fulfilled obligations
5
Art.3.2.15
Preliminary Material
I The content of the duty to restore
1 The general duty: restitution must be in kind or in the form of a monetary payment
1
2
3
2 Accounting for benefits and fruits
4
5
3 Compensation for expenses
6
7
II The consequences of restitution being impossible or inappropriate
8
9
1 When restitution is impossible
10
2 When restitution is inappropriate
11
12
3 The duty to make an allowance in money if restitution is impossible or inappropriate
13
14
15
4 The allocation of the risk that performance cannot be returned due to deterioration or destruction
(a) The general rule: the recipient bears the risk
16
17
18
19
(b) The exception to the general rule: recipient excused if impossibility of making restitution in kind attributable to the other party
20
5 Deterioration or destruction after avoidance
21
22
6 The relationship between duties to restore and duties to pay damages
23
III Application of the general rules relating to obligations to the restitutionary obligations created by Art 3.2.15
24
IV Burden of proof
25
Art.3.2.16
Preliminary Material
I Purpose of Art 3.2.16
1
II Outline
2
3
4
III Contract avoided
1 Overview
5
6
7
2 Liability of party entitled to avoid
8
9
3 Liability of other party
10
IV Contract not avoided
1 Overview
11
12
2 Liability of other party
13
14
15
3 Liability of party entitled to avoid
16
V Burden of proof
17
Art.3.2.17
Preliminary Material
1
s.3: Illegality
Preliminary Material
Selected bibliography
Introduction to Section 3.3 of the PICC
1
Art.3.3.1
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
II Scope
1 Effects of mandatory rules whether or not expressly prescribed
2
3
4
2 Effects upon the contract and remedies under the contract
5
6
7
3 Importance of mandatory rules
8
III Relevance of Art 3.3.1
9
10
11
12
13
IV Criteria of application
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
Art.3.3.2
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
II Criteria for granting restitution
3
4
5
6
III Rules governing restitution
7
8
Ch.4 Interpretation
Preliminary Material
Selected bibliography
Introduction to Chapter 4 of the PICC
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
Art.4.1
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
II Interpretation according to the common intention of the parties, Art 4.1(1)
3
4
III Interpretation according to the understanding of reasonable persons, Art 4.1(2)
5
6
7
IV The relationship between Art 4.1(1) and (2)
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
V Interpretation of standard terms
17
18
19
VI Burden of proof
20
Art.4.2
Preliminary Material
I Statements and other conduct
1
2
II Interpretation according to the intention of the party making the statement or engaging in the conduct, Art 4.2(1)
3
4
5
III Interpretation according to the understanding of reasonable persons, Art 4.2(2)
6
7
IV The relationship between Art 4.2(1) and (2)
8
9
10
V Burden of proof
11
Art.4.3
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
II Relevant circumstances
1 Words used by the parties
3
2 Internal context of the contract, Art 4.4
4
3 Preliminary negotiations between the parties, Art 4.3(a)
5
6
7
4 Practices established between the parties, Art 4.3(b)
8
5 Subsequent conduct of the parties, Art 4.3(c)
9
10
6 Nature and purpose of the contract, Art 4.3(d)
11
12
7 Meaning commonly given to terms and conditions in the trade concerned, Art 4.3(e)
13
14
15
16
8 Usages, Art 4.3(f)
17
18
19
9 Policy arguments
20
21
22
23
III Weight of the relevant circumstances
24
25
26
27
28
29
IV Burden of proof
30
Art.4.4
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
II Reference to the whole contract or statement
3
4
III Inconsistencies in the contract or statement
5
6
IV Weight of arguments from the internal context
7
Art.4.5
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
II Requirements
1 Irremediable ambiguity
3
4
5
6
2 Standard terms
7
III Interpretation giving effect to all the terms
8
Art.4.6
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
3
II Requirements
1 Irremediable ambiguity
4
5
2 Contract terms supplied by one party
6
7
8
III Interpretation against the supplier
9
10
IV Burden of proof
11
Art.4.7
Preliminary Material
I Diverging, but equally authoritative language versions
1
2
3
II Interpretation according to the original version
4
5
6
7
III Burden of proof
8
Art.4.8
Preliminary Material
I Interpretation, supplementation, and implication of contractual terms
1
1 Supplementation and interpretation of terms
2
3
4
5
2 Supplementation and implication of terms
6
7
8
9
II Omission of a term
10
11
12
III Supplementation of an appropriate term
13
14
15
16
Ch.5 Content, third party rights and conditions
s.1: Content
Preliminary Material
Selected bibliography
Art.5.1.1
Art.5.1.2
Preliminary Material
1
Art.5.1.3
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
3
II Duty of co-operation
4
5
6
7
III Limits to the duty
8
9
IV Legal consequences
10
V Burden of proof
11
Art.5.1.4
Preliminary Material
I Distinction between different types of duty
1
2
II Consequences of the distinction
3
4
5
6
7
III Content of the duty of best efforts
8
Art.5.1.5
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
II Criteria for the determination of the kind of duty involved
2
3
4
Art.5.1.6
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
3
II Priority of the general rules of interpretation
4
III Average quality as a minimum threshold
5
6
7
IV Standard of reasonableness
8
V Burden of proof
9
Art.5.1.7
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
3
II Failure to determine the price (Art 5.1.7(1))
1 No determination of the price by the parties
4
5
6
2 Determination of the price according to the market price or a reasonable price
7
8
9
III Determination of the price by one of the parties (Art 5.1.7(2))
10
11
12
13
14
IV Determination of the price by a third person (Art 5.1.7(3))
15
16
17
V Determination of the price with reference to external factors (Art 5.1.7(4))
18
19
20
VI Burden of proof
21
22
23
24
Art.5.1.8
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
3
4
5
II Requirements
1 Contract for an indefinite period
6
7
8
9
2 End of the contract required by good faith
10
3 Notice given a reasonable time in advance
11
12
III Legal consequences
13
IV No exclusion of Art 5.1.8
14
V Burden of proof
15
Art.5.1.9
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
3
II Requirements
1 Agreement
4
5
(a) Offer
6
(b) Acceptance
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
2 No further requirements
14
III Legal consequences
15
IV Burden of proof
16
17
s.2: Third party rights
Preliminary Material
Selected bibliography
Introduction to Section 5.2 of the PICC
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Art.5.2.1
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
II ‘Relativity’ or ‘privity’ of contracts
3
III Validity of contracts in favour of third parties
4
5
IV Conferral of a right on the third party
1 Power of the promisor and the promisee to create third party rights
6
7
8
2 Requirements for the conferral of a right on a third party
9
(a) Agreement of the parties to confer a right on the third party
(1) Agreement conferring a right
10
(2) Express or implied agreement
11
12
13
14
(3) Typical fact patterns
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
(b) No further requirements
27
28
(c) Party autonomy
29
(d) Burden of proof
30
V Content of the beneficiary’s right
31
1 Default rules
32
33
2 Party autonomy
34
35
VI Rights of the promisee
36
VII Invalidity of contracts to the detriment of third parties
37
38
Art.5.2.2
Preliminary Material
I Rationale of the provision
1
II Existence of the third party
2
III Identity of the third party
3
4
5
6
7
IV Legal capacity of the third party
8
Art.5.2.3
Preliminary Material
I Beneficiary’s ‘right’ to invoke a clause
1
II Clause excluding or limiting the liability of the beneficiary
2
3
4
III Burden of proof
5
Art.5.2.4
Preliminary Material
I Defences of the promisor against the promisee
1 Availability of defences
1
2
2 Party autonomy
3
3 Burden of proof
4
II Defences of the promisor against the beneficiary
5
Art.5.2.5
Preliminary Material
I Right of the parties to modify or revoke the beneficiary’s right
1
II Consequences of modification and revocation
2
III Joint agreement of the parties
3
IV Effecting modification and revocation
4
V Immutability and irrevocability
5
6
7
8
VI Burden of proof
9
Art.5.2.6
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
II Renunciation
3
4
5
III Consequences of renunciation
6
IV Burden of proof
7
s.3: Conditions
Preliminary Material
Selected bibliography
Introduction to Section 5.3 of the PICC
1
2
3
Art.5.3.1
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
3
II The scope of Section 5.3
1 Conditions imposed by law
4
2 Both contracts and obligations can be made conditional
5
III Defining the notion of ‘condition’
6
7
8
9
IV The distinction between ‘suspensive’ and ‘resolutive’ conditions
10
11
12
13
14
15
V Conditions whose fulfilment is entirely dependent on the will of the obligor
16
17
18
19
20
VI Time limit stated by the condition
21
VII Illegal conditions
22
Art.5.3.2
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
II Non-retroactivity as a principle
2
3
4
5
III The effect of suspensive conditions
6
1 Before fulfilment or failure of the condition
7
8
2 On the fulfilment or failure of the condition
9
10
IV The effect of resolutive conditions
11
1 Before fulfilment or failure of the condition
12
2 Upon fulfilment or failure of the condition
13
14
Art.5.3.3
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
3
II Interference that breaches the duties of good faith and co-operation
4
5
6
7
8
III Duty to use all reasonable efforts to cause the condition to be fulfilled
9
IV Remedies for interference with the fulfilment of a condition
10
1 Absence of express provision on remedies
11
12
2 Fictional fulfilment and non-fulfilment of the condition
13
14
15
16
17
18
3 Choice of remedies available to the innocent party following wrongful interference
19
20
21
4 Illustrations in the Official Comment
22
(a) The interfering party prevents fulfilment of a suspensive condition
23
24
25
26
(b) The interfering party procures fulfilment of a suspensive condition
27
28
(c) The interfering party prevents fulfilment of a resolutive condition
29
(d) The interfering party procures fulfilment of a resolutive condition
30
31
(e) The future evolution of Art 5.3.3
32
33
Art.5.3.4
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
3
4
II Prejudicial act that breaches the duty of good faith and fair dealing
5
6
III The relationship between Arts 5.3.3 and 5.3.4
7
8
IV Remedies for breach of Art 5.3.4
9
10
11
V The intensity of the obligation
12
Art.5.3.5
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
3
4
II The scope of Art 5.3.5
5
6
III Restitution where the resolutive condition operates prospectively (Art 5.3.5(1))
7
8
9
10
11
12
IV Restitution where the resolutive condition operates retroactively (Art 5.3.5(2))
13
14
15
V With ‘appropriate adaptations’
16
17
Ch.6 Performance
s.1: Performance in general
Preliminary Material
Selected bibliography
Art.6.1.1
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
II Notion of timely performance and consequences of untimely performance
1 Timely performance in general
3
4
2 Timely payment
5
3 Legal consequences related to untimely performance
6
III Time of performance fixed by the parties
7
1 Determination of time or period
8
9
2 Ambiguous terms regarding time of performance
10
11
12
3 Discretion to fix exact time of performance
13
14
15
16
IV Time of performance according to the default rule
1 Performance within a reasonable time after conclusion of the contract
17
18
19
2 Deficiencies of the default rule
20
21
22
V Obligee’s failure to co-operate in regard to timely performance
23
VI Changes in time of performance
24
VII Burden of proof
25
Art.6.1.2
Preliminary Material
I Performance at one time as a rule
1
2
II Exception: performance in instalments
3
III Effect on counter-performance
4
IV Burden of proof
5
Art.6.1.3
Preliminary Material
I Content and scope of application
1
2
3
II Definition of partial performance
4
5
6
III Status of the obligee
1 Right to reject partial performance
7
8
2 Obligation to accept partial performance
9
10
11
12
13
14
IV Legal consequences of acceptance or rejection of partial performance
1 Acceptance of partial performance
15
16
17
18
19
2 Rejection of partial performance
20
21
V Special topics: right of rejection in case of only partly possible performance, defective performance, and performance in excess
22
23
24
25
VI Burden of proof
26
Art.6.1.4
Preliminary Material
I Content and scope of application
1
2
3
4
5
II The role of Art 6.1.4 in determining the time of performance for the counter-performance
6
7
III The role of Art 6.1.4 in determining the order of performance of due obligations
1 Rule: simultaneous performance
8
9
10
2 Exception: duty to render performance first
11
12
13
IV Performances to be taken into consideration when determining the time and order of performance
14
15
16
V Legal consequences of disregarding the order of performance
17
VI Burden of proof
18
Art.6.1.5
Preliminary Material
I Rule: no early performance allowed
1
2
3
II Exception: no legitimate interest in refusing early performance
4
5
6
III Consequences of acceptance of early performance
1 Additional expenses
7
2 Remedies for non-performance
8
9
3 Right of obligor to discount
10
4 Time of counter-performance
11
12
Art.6.1.6
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
II Relevance of place of performance
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
III Place of performance determined or determinable from the contract
1 Express stipulations
9
2 Implied stipulations
10
3 Problems related to interpretation of stipulations regarding place of performance
(a) Multiplicity of places of performance
11
(b) Stipulations in sales contracts involving carriage
12
13
14
(c) Stipulations regarding payment
15
16
IV Default rule for determining place of performance
1 Principle: performance at the place of business of the obligor
17
2 Exception for monetary obligations: performance at the place of business of the obligee
18
19
3 No special default rule for specific items
20
V Place of performance for non-performance and restitution claims
21
22
VI Notion of place of business and consequences of a change in place of business or a change of parties
23
24
25
26
27
28
VII Legal consequences related to performance at a wrong place
29
30
VIII Burden of proof
31
Art.6.1.7
Preliminary Material
I Cashless payment in general and the payment methods accepted by the PICC
1
2
3
4
5
6
II Structure of cashless payment methods and their systematization: ‘push-orders’ and ‘pull-orders’
7
8
9
III Payment through pull-orders
1 Effects of acceptance of a pull-order on the payment obligation
10
11
12
2 Place and time of performance of pull-order
13
3 Risk of loss or theft of pull-order
14
4 Risk of pull-orders being dishonoured
15
Art.6.1.8
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
II Place of performance for fund transfers
2
III Financial institution and account of the obligee
3
4
IV Time when the obligation is discharged
5
6
7
8
9
V Timely performance
10
VI Countermand
11
VII Delay or loss in the process of transferring funds
12
13
Art.6.1.9
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
II Right of obligor to pay in either contractual or legal currency
3
III Right of obligee to request payment in either contractual or legal currency
4
1 Payment in contractual currency
5
6
7
2 Payment in legal currency
8
9
10
IV Rate of exchange
1 Rate applied when payment is on time
11
2 Rate applied when the obligor is in default
12
13
14
V Problems related to devaluation or revaluation
15
VI Burden of proof
16
Art.6.1.10
Preliminary Material
1
2
3
4
5
6
Art.6.1.11
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
3
II Costs of performance when place of performance lies with the obligor
4
5
III Costs of performance when place of performance lies with the obligee
6
7
IV Costs of performance when place of performance is a third place
8
V Costs due to changes in the place of performance
9
VI Reimbursement of costs
10
Art.6.1.12
Preliminary Material
I Scope of application and taxonomy
1
2
3
II Obligor’s right to impute
4
5
6
7
III Obligee’s subsidiary right to impute
8
9
10
11
IV Imputation by law
1 Missing imputation by the parties
12
2 The sequence and criteria of imputation
13
(a) Maturity
14
15
(b) Security
16
17
(c) Cumbersomeness
18
(d) Age
19
(e) Pro rata
20
3 Deviations from the legal sequence based on the presumed intentions of the parties
21
22
V Applicability of Art 6.1.12 in the case of partial payment
23
VI Burden of proof
24
Art.6.1.13
Preliminary Material
1
2
3
Art.6.1.14
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
II Concept of public permission requirements
1 Sources of public permission requirements
3
2 Notion of public permission requirements
4
5
6
III Party required to apply for public permission
1 In general
7
2 According to the law
8
3 According to the contract
9
10
4 According to the circumstances
11
12
5 According to the default rule
(a) Party with place of business in state requiring public permission
13
(b) Party whose performance requires public permission
14
IV Nature of obligation to take necessary measures
15
16
17
V Duty to disclose public permission requirements and to co-operate
18
19
VI Legal effects of missing public permission
1 On the contract and its performance
20
21
2 On the application of non-performance remedies
22
23
VII Burden of proof
24
Art.6.1.15
Preliminary Material
I Time of application for the permission
1
2
II Expenses related to permission
3
III Duty to give notice of results of application
1 Duty to give notice
4
5
2 Consequences of late or missing notification
6
7
Art.6.1.16
Preliminary Material
I Application for permission filed but no decision taken
1
2
3
II Consequences if missing permission affects the contract in general
4
5
6
III Consequences if missing permission affects only certain terms of the contract
7
Art.6.1.17
Preliminary Material
I Application for permission refused
1
II Refusal affects validity of contract
2
3
4
III Refusal renders performance impossible
5
6
s.2: Hardship
Preliminary Material
Selected bibliography
Introduction to Section 6.2 of the PICC
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
Art.6.2.1
Preliminary Material
1
2
3
4
Art.6.2.2
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
II Fundamental alteration of the equilibrium of the contract
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
III The requirements of Art 6.2.2(a)–(d)
10
11
12
13
14
15
Art.6.2.3
Preliminary Material
I Disadvantaged party entitled to request renegotiations
1
2
3
II Withholding performance
4
III Resort to the court
5
IV Court measures
6
7
8
9
10
V Burden of proof
11
Ch.7 Non-performance
s.1: Non-performance in general
Preliminary Material
Selected bibliography
Introduction to Section 7.1 of the PICC
Preliminary Material
I Structure
1
II Relationship between the different remedies
1 Choice of remedy
2
3
2 Accumulation of remedies
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
3 Non-performance and mistake
11
III General limitations to remedies for non-performance
12
13
14
Art.7.1.1
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1 Unitary concept: any non-performance
1
2 Reasons for non-performance
2
3
4
3 No general concept of ‘default’
5
4 Terminology
6
5 Burden of proof
7
II Non-performance defined
1 The content of the contract
8
2 Non-performance and non-conformity
9
3 Vicarious liability for contractual obligations
10
Art.7.1.2
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
II Interference by the other party
1 Non-performance caused by the obligee
3
4
5
2 Non-performance due to an event for which the obligee bears the risk
6
7
8
3 Partial interference
9
10
III Legal consequences
11
IV Burden of proof
12
13
14
15
Art.7.1.3
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
II Requirements
1 Non-performance of the other party
(a) Due claim on the other party
8
9
10
11
12
(b) No fundamental non-performance required
13
2 No notice required
14
3 Sufficient connection between the obligations
(a) General
15
16
(b) The contract provides for rules
17
(c) Reciprocal or synallagmatic contracts
18
19
(d) No contractual rules, no synallagmatic contract
20
21
22
III Order of performance
23
24
25
26
IV Partial performance
27
28
29
V Legal consequences
1 No non-performance
30
2 Withholding performance and title
31
Art.7.1.4
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
3
4
5
II Requirements
1 General
6
7
8
2 Notice
9
10
3 Appropriateness of cure
11
12
13
14
15
4 No legitimate interest of the aggrieved party in refusing cure
16
17
18
19
5 Prompt cure
20
21
III Cure even after a notice of termination, Art 7.1.4(2)
22
IV Legal consequences
1 Suspension of inconsistent remedies
23
2 Damages
24
3 Withholding performance
25
4 Obligation to co-operate
26
27
Art.7.1.5
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
3
4
5
II Requirements
6
7
8
9
10
III Legal consequences
1 Withholding performance
11
2 Damages and contractual penalties
12
13
3 No other remedies
14
15
4 Legal consequences of the lapse of the additional time limit
(a) All remedies available
16
(b) Termination
(1) Termination in cases of persisting non-performance
17
18
(2) Reasonable period of time
19
20
21
22
(3) Cases where the contract may not be terminated after the lapse of time
23
24
25
Art.7.1.6
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
3
II Exemption clause
4
5
6
7
III ‘Grossly unfair’
1 Starting point
8
9
10
11
12
13
2 Intentional or grossly negligent conduct
14
15
3 Performance substantially different
16
4 Purpose of the contract
17
18
5 Exemption clause in standard terms
19
6 Other relevant factors
20
21
22
IV Legal consequences
23
24
Art.7.1.7
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
II Relationship with contractual practice
11
12
13
14
15
16
III Art 7.1.7(1) as a default rule
17
18
19
1 Impediment
20
21
22
2 Impediment beyond the control of the obligor
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
3 Event not reasonably foreseeable
33
34
35
4 Notice of force majeure
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
IV Consequences of force majeure
43
44
45
46
47
48
V Burden of proof
49
50
s.2: Right to performance
Preliminary Material
Selected bibliography
Introduction to Section 7.2 of the PICC
1
2
3
Art.7.2.1
Preliminary Material
I General
1
2
3
II ‘Monetary obligation’
4
III Conditions
5
IV Currency
6
V Exception
7
8
Art.7.2.2
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
3
4
5
II Starting point: performance as the primary remedy
1 Conditions
6
7
8
2 Order to perform
9
10
11
12
III Exceptions
1 General
13
14
15
16
17
2 Impossibility of performance, Art 7.2.2(a)
(a) Impossibility in law or fact
18
19
(b) Definition
20
21
22
23
(c) Legal consequences
24
3 Unreasonably burdensome or expensive, Art 7.2.2(b)
(a) General
25
26
(b) Costs and benefits
27
28
29
(c) Change of circumstances
30
31
(d) Enforcement unreasonably burdensome or expensive
32
33
4 Replacement transaction, Art 7.2.2(c)
(a) Replacement transaction
34
35
36
(b) ‘Reasonableness’ of replacement transaction
37
38
39
(c) Legal consequences
40
41
5 Performance of an exclusively personal character, Art 7.2.2(d)
(a) General
42
43
(b) Definition
44
45
(c) Exception: obligation to abstain from doing something
46
6 Request within a reasonable time, Art 7.2.2(e)
(a) General rule
47
48
49
(b) Two time limits
(1) General
50
51
(2) First time limit: inspection for defective performance
52
53
(3) Second time limit: performance within a reasonable time
54
55
56
(c) Contractual time limit
57
(d) Legal consequences
58
Art.7.2.3
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
3
4
5
6
II Repair, replacement, and other cure
1 General
7
2 Repair
8
9
10
11
12
3 Replacement
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
4 Other cure
20
III Repair and replacement with respect to payment of money
21
Art.7.2.4
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
3
4
5
II ‘Judicial penalty’
6
III Discretionary power
7
8
9
IV Beneficiary: the aggrieved party
1 General
10
2 Mandatory provisions with regard to the beneficiary: lex fori
11
3 Refusal to pay
12
13
14
V Judicial penalty and damages
15
Art.7.2.5
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
3
II Requirements
1 General
4
2 No performance after expiry of period of time, Art 7.2.5(1)
5
6
3 Unenforceable decision, Art 7.2.5(2)
7
III Time limit for a notice of termination
8
IV Performance incompatible with other remedies
9
s.3: Termination
Preliminary Material
Selected bibliography
Introduction to Section 7.3 of the PICC
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Art.7.3.1
Preliminary Material
I Purpose of the provision
1 Outline
1
2
3
4
2 Policy considerations underlying Art 7.3.1
5
6
II Freedom of contract
7
III Termination for fundamental non-performance, Art 7.3.1(1) and (2)
1 Non-performance
8
9
10
11
2 Fundamental non-performance
(a) Weighing of factors in each individual case
12
13
14
(b) Comparative parallels
15
16
17
18
3 ‘Foreseeable substantial deprivation’, Art 7.3.1(2)(a)
19
(a) Substantial deprivation
20
21
22
23
24
(1) Contractual agreement
25
(2) Seriousness of the breach
26
(3) Reasonable use test
27
28
29
30
31
32
(4) Not relevant: right to cure
33
(b) Foreseeability
34
35
36
37
38
4 ‘Strict compliance’, Art 7.3.1(2)(b)
39
(a) Contractual agreement
40
(b) Circumstances of the case
41
42
5 ‘Intention’, Art 7.3.1(2)(c)
43
44
45
6 ‘Loss of reliance’, Art 7.3.1(2)(d)
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
7 ‘Disproportionate loss’, Art 7.3.1(2)(e)
58
59
60
61
8 Use of the Nachfrist procedure within the concept of fundamental non-performance
62
9 Specific case scenarios
63
64
(a) Delay in performance
65
66
67
68
69
70
(b) Definite non-performance
71
72
(c) Non-conforming performance
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
(d) Documents
85
86
(e) Breach of ancillary obligations
87
IV Termination after expiry of an additional period of time for performance
88
89
90
91
V Use of the Nachfrist procedure within the doctrine of fundamental non-performance
92
VI Termination for partial non-performance
93
94
95
96
VII Burden of proof
97
VIII Effects of termination
98
Art.7.3.2
Preliminary Material
I Purpose of the provision
1
II Notice
2
3
4
III Time limit
5
1 Types of non-performance
6
7
8
9
2 Reasonable time
10
11
12
13
14
IV Burden of proof
15
Art.7.3.3
Preliminary Material
I Purpose of the provision
1
2
II Requirements for the right to terminate
3
1 ‘Prior to the date for performance’
4
2 Standard of probability
5
3 Fundamental non-performance
6
7
4 Notice of termination
8
9
5 No demand for adequate assurance required
10
6 Examples
11
12
III Effects of termination
13
Art.7.3.4
Preliminary Material
I Purpose of the provision
1
2
II Adequate assurance of performance and right to withhold own performance, Art 7.3.4(1)
1 Requirements
(a) Prior to the date of performance
3
(b) Standard of probability
4
5
(c) Fundamental non-performance
6
2 Consequences
(a) Adequate assurance of performance
7
8
9
10
11
(b) Right to withhold own performance
12
13
III Termination, Art 7.3.4(2)
14
15
16
Art.7.3.5
Preliminary Material
I Overview
1
II Release from future performance obligations
2
3
III No exclusion of claims for damages
4
IV Autonomy of ‘termination-resistant’ provisions
5
6
V Effects of unlawful termination
7
VI Proprietary aspects
8
9
Art.7.3.6
Preliminary Material
I Overview
1
2
3
II Contracts to be performed at one time
4
III Concurrent restitution, Art 7.3.6(1)
5
IV Reasonable allowance, Art 7.3.6(2) and (3)
6
1 Restitution in kind impossible
7
2 Restitution in kind not appropriate
8
3 Allowance in money whenever reasonable
9
(a) Concurrent obligations
10
(b) Measure
11
(c) Reasonableness criterion
12
4 Risk allocation, Art 7.3.6(3)
13
14
15
16
17
V Compensation for expenses, Art 7.3.6(4)
18
19
20
21
VI No rule concerning benefits
22
23
24
VII Application of the general rules
25
1 Time, place, and details of performance
26
27
28
2 Rules on non-performance
29
30
31
VIII Rights of third parties
32
IX Burden of proof
33
Art.7.3.7
Preliminary Material
I Overview
1
II Contract to be performed over a period of time
2
3
4
III Divisibility
5
IV Extent of restitution
6
7
s.4: Damages
Preliminary Material
Selected bibliography
Introduction to Section 7.4 of the PICC
1
2
3
4
5
6
Art.7.4.1
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
II ‘Any non-performance’
2
III ‘A right to damages’
3
IV ‘Exclusively or in conjunction with any other remedies’
4
5
V Excused non-performance
6
VI Analogical application
7
8
VII Burden of proof
9
Art.7.4.2
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
II Full compensation
2
3
4
5
III Harm sustained as a result of the non-performance
6
1 Loss suffered
7
8
9
10
2 Deprivation of gain
11
3 No enrichment
12
4 Changes in the harm
13
14
5 Non-pecuniary harm
15
16
17
18
19
20
IV As a result of the non-performance
21
22
V Burden of proof
23
Art.7.4.3
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
II A reasonable degree of certainty
2
III Loss of a chance
3
4
IV Discretion
5
V The choice to be made
6
7
8
VI The causal link: a reprise
9
VII Burden of proof
10
Art.7.4.4
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
II Foresight
3
4
5
III ‘Could reasonably have foreseen’
6
IV ‘At the time of the conclusion of the contract’
7
V ‘Likely to result’
8
VI Insignificance of intentional or grossly negligent non-performance
9
VII Burden of proof
10
Art.7.4.5
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
3
II ‘Terminated the contract’
4
III ‘Replacement transaction’
5
6
IV ‘Within a reasonable time’
7
V ‘In a reasonable manner’
8
VI Overlap with Art 7.4.8
9
VII The measure of recovery
1 The minimum right of recovery
10
2 ‘Damages for any further harm’
11
VIII Burden of proof
12
Art.7.4.6
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
II Termination and no replacement transaction
2
III Current price
3
IV No current price
4
V The measure of recovery
1 An abstract rule
5
2 ‘Damages for any further harm’
6
VI Burden of proof
7
Art.7.4.7
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
3
II ‘Due to’
4
III ‘Act or omission of the aggrieved party’
5
IV An event for which the non-performing party bears the risk
6
V Apportionment
7
VI Burden of proof
8
Art.7.4.8
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
II ‘Reasonable steps’ to reduce the harm
3
4
III ‘Could have been reduced’
5
IV ‘Is not liable for harm suffered’
6
V ‘Expenses reasonably incurred’
7
VI Related doctrines
8
VII Burden of proof
9
Art.7.4.9
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
3
4
II The scope of the right
5
1 Failure to pay a sum of money when it falls due
6
7
2 The time at which the right arises
8
9
3 ‘Whether or not the non-payment is excused’
10
III Rate of interest
11
12
13
14
15
IV Contracting out
16
V Additional damages
17
VI Burden of proof
18
Art.7.4.10
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
II Interest on damages for non-performance of non-monetary obligations
2
III The time at which the right accrues
3
IV ‘Unless otherwise agreed’
4
V The rate of interest
5
VI Compound interest
6
VII ‘Avoidance of double compensation’
7
8
VIII Burden of proof
9
Art.7.4.11
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
II Damages to be paid in a lump sum
2
III The exceptional case
3
4
IV Indexation
5
Art.7.4.12
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
II The currency in which the monetary obligation was expressed
2
III The currency in which the harm was suffered
3
IV The choice to be made
4
Art.7.4.13
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
II The scope of Art 7.4.13
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
III Specified sum
12
IV Non-performance
13
V Entitlement to recover specified sum
14
VI Valid irrespective of actual harm
15
VII Except where grossly excessive
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
VIII Burden of proof
23
Ch.8 Set-off
Preliminary Material
Selected bibliography
Introduction to Chapter 8 of the PICC
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
Art.8.1
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
3
4
II Set-off and jurisdiction (arbitration)
5
6
7
8
9
10
III Mutuality of obligations
1 Mutuality of obligations and capacity
11
12
13
2 Third party set-off
14
15
IV Obligations of the same kind
1 ‘Same kind’ and the nature of the obligations
16
17
18
19
20
2 ‘Same kind’ and the terms of the obligations
21
22
23
V Right to perform and enforceability
24
1 Right to perform for the party declaring set-off (‘performable’), Art 8.1(1)(a)
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
2 Enforceability of the obligation of the other party
32
33
34
35
VI The other party’s obligation must be ascertained, Art 8.1(1)(b) and Art 8.1(2)
36
1 The notion of ascertainment, Art 8.1(1)(b)
37
38
39
40
41
2 The notion of ‘the same contract’ under Art 8.1(2)
42
43
44
45
46
3 Obligation easily ascertained
47
48
VII Burden of proof
49
Art.8.2
Preliminary Material
I Overview
1
II Set-off for freely convertible currencies
1 The principle
2
3
4
5
6
7
2 Conversion and the exchange rate
8
9
10
11
III Restriction to set-off between foreign currencies
12
1 Set-off in currencies that are not freely convertible
13
2 Currency imposed by agreement
14
15
16
17
IV Burden of proof
18
Art.8.3
Preliminary Material
I The requirement of notice
1 The principle of set-off by notice
1
2
3
4
5
6
2 Form of notice of set-off
7
8
9
3 Time to give notice (‘anticipatory notice’)
10
11
12
II Other modes of set-off
13
1 Set-off within insolvency proceedings
(a) The relationship between the PICC and domestic insolvency rules
14
15
16
17
(b) The security effect of set-off in insolvency
18
19
2 Set-off by agreement
20
21
III Burden of proof
22
Art.8.4
Preliminary Material
I Specification of notice
1
2
3
4
5
6
II Consequences of absence of specification by the first party
7
8
9
1 Multiple obligations of the other party
10
11
12
13
2 Multiple obligations of the first party
14
15
16
17
18
3 Multiple obligations on both sides
19
III Burden of proof
20
Art.8.5
Preliminary Material
I The discharging effect
1 The principle
1
2 Scope of the discharging effect
2
3
3 Prospective effect
4
5
6
7
II Specific consequences
8
9
10
11
12
13
III Burden of proof
14
Ch.9 Assignment of rights, transfer of obligations, assignment of contracts
Preliminary Material
Selected bibliography
Introduction to Chapter 9 of the PICC
Preliminary Material
I Balance of interests
1
II International instruments
2
III The structure of Chapter 9
3
4
5
6
IV Distinctive features of Section 9.1 of the PICC
1 Distinction between rights to payment of a monetary sum and other performance
7
8
2 Leaving aside notions of domestic law
9
3 Third parties
(a) Protection of the debtor
10
(b) Interests of the assignor’s creditors
11
V Evaluation
12
13
s.1: Assignment of rights
Art.9.1.1
Preliminary Material
I Terminology
1
2
II Notion of transfer
3
4
5
III Transfer by agreement between assignor and assignee
6
1 No legal transfers
7
8
2 No unilateral transfers
9
10
11
3 Economic rationale of the transfer
12
4 No participation of the obligor
13
5 No form required
14
6 Promise to assign
15
7 Sub-assignments
16
IV Object of the transfer
17
18
19
20
21
V Relevant time
22
Art.9.1.2
Preliminary Material
1
2
3
4
Art.9.1.3
Preliminary Material
I Background
1
II Obligations significantly more burdensome
2
3
4
III Effects
5
6
7
IV Party autonomy
8
9
Art.9.1.4
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
II Payment of a monetary sum
2
III Other performance
3
1 Divisibility
4
2 Additional burden
5
IV Effects
6
7
V Party autonomy
8
9
Art.9.1.5
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
II Future right
3
4
5
III Identification
1 Relevant elements
6
2 Relevant time
7
8
9
3 Time and effort
10
4 Irrelevance of the obligor’s perspective for the effectiveness of the assignment
11
IV Effects if right comes into existence
1 Retroactivity
12
13
2 Relevant time
14
3 Technical details of the transfer
15
V Effects if right does not come into existence
16
VI Party autonomy
17
18
Art.9.1.6
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
2
II Identification and relevant time
3
III Partial validity
4
5
6
Art.9.1.7
Preliminary Material
I Introduction
1
II No formal requirements
2
III Relevant time
3
IV Effectiveness inter partes or erga omnes
4
V Consent of the obligor
5
6
7
8
VI Burden of proof
9
VII Party autonomy
10
Art.9.1.8
Preliminary Material
I Background
1
2
II Additional costs
3
1 Change of place of performance
4
2 Partial assignments
5
III Choice between assignor and assignee
6
IV Party autonomy
7
Art.9.1.9
Preliminary Material
I Background
1
2
II Rights to payment of a monetary sum, Art 9.1.9(1)
3
1 Violation of a non-assignment clause
(a) Agreement
4
(b) Parties to the agreement
5
(c) Agreement limiting or prohibiting the assignment
6
7
(d) Object of the non-assignment clause
8
2 Legal consequences
(a) Assignment effective, Art 9.1.9(1)(1)
9
10
(b) Liability of the assignor, Art 9.1.9(1)(2)
11
III Rights to a non-monetary performance, Art 9.1.9(2)
12
1 Violation of non-assignment clause
13
2 Legal consequences
(a) General rule: assignment ineffective, Art 9.1.9(2)(1)
14
(b) Exception: no knowledge of the assignee, Art 9.1.9(2)(2)
15
(1) Assignee neither knew nor ought to have known of the non-assignment clause
16
17
(2) Relevant time
18
(3) Liability of the assignor, Art 9.1.9(2)(3)
19
IV Party autonomy
20
21
Art.9.1.10
Preliminary Material
I Rationale and effects of the notice
1
2
3
II Valid notice
1 Art 1.10 PICC
4
2 Content of the notice
5
6
3 Language
7
4 Person giving notice
8
5 No obligation to give notice
9
III Notice instead of knowledge
10
11
12
13
14
IV Rights to non-monetary performance
15
V Relevant time
16
VI Revocation
17
VII Party autonomy
18
Art.9.1.11
Preliminary Material
I Scope
1
2
3
II Successive assignments by the same assignor
4
5
6
III Same right
7
IV First in time rule
1 Rule
8
9
10
2 No effective notice
11
3 Remedy of the assignee which does not prevail
12
4 Knowledge of the obligor in the absence of notice
13
V Party autonomy
14
Art.9.1.12
Preliminary Material
I Rationale and scope
1
2
II Adequate proof
3
4
III Timing
5
IV Effects
6
7
8
9
V Party autonomy
10
Art.9.1.13
Preliminary Material
I Defences, Art 9.1.13(1)
1
2
3
1 The notion of defences
4
5
6
7
8
9
2 Time at which the defences come into existence
10
11
12
3 Procedural defences
13
4 Waiver
14
5 Remedy of the assignee
15
6 Party autonomy
16
II Rights of set-off, Art 9.1.13(2)
1 Scope of application and rationale
17
18
19
20
2 Requirements
21
22
23
24
25
3 Burden of proof
26
4 Consequences in the case of notice of set-off
27
28
29
Art.9.1.14
Preliminary Material
I Rule
1
2
3
II Exceptions
1 Partial assignment
4
2 Assignment contrary to a clause limiting or prohibiting assignment
5
III Mandatory rules and party autonomy
6
Art.9.1.15
Preliminary Material
I The different undertakings
1 Existence of the right, Art 9.1.15(a)
1
2
2 Assignor entitled to assign the right, Art 9.1.15(b)
3
3 No previous assignment, no third party rights or claims, Art 9.1.15(c)
4
5
4 No defence from the obligor, Art 9.1.15(d)
6
5 No notice of set-off, Art 9.1.15(e)
7
6 Reimbursement of payment by the obligor, Art 9.1.15(f)
8
II Effects
9
III Party autonomy
10
11
s.2: Transfer of obligations
Art.9.2.1
Preliminary Material
I Terminology
1
2
II Notion of transfer
3
III Transfer by agreement
1 No legal transfers
4
2 No form required
5
IV Participation of the obligee
6
V Object of the transfer
7
8
VI Relevant time
9
10
Art.9.2.2
Preliminary Material
1
2
Art.9.2.3
Preliminary Material
I Consent of the obligee required
1
2
3
II Lack of consent
4
III Situation before consent is given or refused
5
Art.9.2.4
Preliminary Material
I Advance consent
1
II Consequence
2
3
Art.9.2.5
Preliminary Material
I Default rule: joint and several liability (Art 9.2.5(3))
1
2
II Original obligor fully discharged (Art 9.2.5(1))
3
III Original obligor retained (Art 9.2.5(2))
4
IV Declaration of choice (Art 9.2.5(3))
5
Art.9.2.6
Preliminary Material
1
2
3
Art.9.2.7
Preliminary Material
I Defences, Art 9.2.7(1)
1
1 The notion of defences
2
3
4
5
6
7
2 Time at which the defences come into existence
8
9
3 Procedural defences
10